The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

Bids for my 200 C$ Auction (It was 197 but i ended up getting 200.)
Which is the most fair? @Gasoline
BID 1: 5/10 I like the true dates and the list, but not for sure what im looking for.
BID 2: 7.5/10 Nice bid!! But i feel as if horses and rats a bit hard to trade away
BID 3: 4.5/10 I dont really like most of the pets, i feel as if bunnies, horses and rats are hard to get trades for!
BID 4: 1/10 the 2018 rare is no where near 200 Chicken dollars
BID 5: ??/10 I know for su
BID 6 ??/10

[gummyrino]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76333588&userid=727958&signature=rHuD212r7Tx5FpOVlh90Hg
Is this fair! Thanks!

your '14 store pets are worth an '09 rare each and the '11 is worth 2-3 '09 rares. considering the VR dog is late '08 this is overpay on your side. they'd have to add 3-4 '09 rares

The dog is a list pet ^^ (I'm on the other side of the trade)

[meodencon01]

Is this fair for PPS dragon cat?

[.dylan.]

Is this fair for PPS dragon cat?

it really depends on who you trade. a mid advent alone is usually around what it is so if i was planning to trade mine i would definitely take this. i personally got mine for 100C$

[Begs]

Should I accept this?! trades/viewtrade.php?id=76292124&userid=858203&signature=m4nSJtLPM55-2J8pRKWEeQ

[starpups16]

Fair??????

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76348519&userid=942301&signature=c185ac34YnPogfkOaKy7MA

[GhostPants]

Bids for my 200 C$ Auction (It was 197 but i ended up getting 200.)
Which is the most fair? @Gasoline
BID 1: 5/10 I like the true dates and the list, but not for sure what im looking for.
BID 2: 7.5/10 Nice bid!! But i feel as if horses and rats a bit hard to trade away
BID 3: 4.5/10 I dont really like most of the pets, i feel as if bunnies, horses and rats are hard to get trades for!
BID 4: 1/10 the 2018 rare is no where near 200 Chicken dollars
BID 5: ??/10 I know for su
BID 6 ??/10

[Demonking Urizen]

hoi!
I've held a quantity rat auction for my alicorn PPS and now I want to know
which of these two bids are better, and if they are even fair.

xx 1 xx
xx 2 xx



this is the pet they bid on.

thank you!

I'd really like to know it because I want to choose the winner.

[darkjellies]

Should I accept this?! trades/viewtrade.php?id=76292124&userid=858203&signature=m4nSJtLPM55-2J8pRKWEeQ

Short answer: I think the trade is perfectly fair, it honestly just depends on what you like the most.
Detailed answer: The pet you have is the red rose: a mid September list. The two pets you're being offered are the pale pink/blue spotted and the pink striped September. The pink striped September is also a September list but, as it's slightly lower is worth less. Though, when combined with an advent list (like the pale pink/blue spotted) is worth the red rose. You could probably get more for the red rose but if you're not looking for overpay then it's good and you should accept. If you are looking for overpay or don't want to trade down then cancel.

[Magicmetal]

Ehh is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76346722

We’ve gone back and forth a little now.. won’t give me more than 2