The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lopez]

Hello! I'd like an opinion on this trade please. Is it fair, and if not, what would they need to add?

Thanks in advance!!

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76159051&userid=812148&signature=Oplb6mPxEVVozC5CJ9PiFg


is this fair?? thanks!

It was unfair to you. Your Corgi Store Pet is worth about a mid '09 rare (extended into 2014), that Skeleton Dog is only a 2010 rare. ^^

[mthorsewhisperer]

little help with this?
thank you!!

[nobxdy]

little help with this?
thank you!!

It's about fair / slight overpay on their side with the added pet (but not much). Their dog is originally from Valentine's Day 2009, so according to the 3 month rule, this is fair. ^^

[killukawa]

Is the sunback worth a non jewel and UR peas?? Or is it an under hehh

[nobxdy]

Is the sunback worth a non jewel and UR peas?? Or is it an under hehh

The Sunback is worth 2 Nons, and typically goes for more. I'd say it's unfair to the Sunback because the UR Peas typically only goes for 1-2 Sorbets, so that's less than 2 Nons worth on the Non-Jewel and UR Peas side.

However, it's really up to how you and your partner personally value the pets involved. ^^

[killukawa]

Is the sunback worth a non jewel and UR peas?? Or is it an under hehh

The Sunback is worth 2 Nons, and typically goes for more. I'd say it's unfair to the Sunback because the UR Peas typically only goes for 1-2 Sorbets, so that's less than 2 Nons worth on the Non-Jewel and UR Peas side.

However, it's really up to how you and your partner personally value the pets involved. ^^

Also wondering if you could help me with this trade trades/viewtrade.php?id=76159196&userid=866559&signature=uIcnbtNvYwqa5muqxY7E6A ? ❤

[nobxdy]

-snip-

Also wondering if you could help me with this trade trades/viewtrade.php?id=76159196&userid=866559&signature=uIcnbtNvYwqa5muqxY7E6A ? ❤

Looks unfair to you. Their side looks like it doesn't add up to a 2009 rare at all. Get a second opinion though, idk what the item is worth. <3

[GhostPants]

Not really sure?
do the UC close the year gap?

[xXStylishXx]

Hey!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76148707&userid=809505&signature=Dq_8Kz-YXqp0nju515U55Q
I have a question about this trade; currently there's nothing, however it is an editable trade and they're offering my choice of their pets. The pet they would like me to trade to them is:

this stripey boi. I'm rather unfamiliar with rarity so I need some help, and I don't know what would be a fair trade?

Thank chuuu