The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.dylan.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121640&userid=673904&signature=-V4HJ18d9Ohy4iQ7z-WWvw should i accept?

[TheKwakiutlTribe]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121583&userid=710778&signature=kQTsIqsLerjqksTRTqOtuw

Is this fair? Thanks to everyone who helps!

[Camden]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121637&userid=889724&signature=I4ZwvOP-gr2f_FeZfuEcXw
Is this fair?
Thanks in advance!!

[♦【uta】♦]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121305&userid=785453&signature=drK52UtB7WWeYMYXnyBPqw

is this fair? it's 256 totems

This is more a personal opinion than anything:

I wouldn't accept this.
If I mathed correctly {which I probs didn't, lol} it looks to me that the person who sent this is valuing your totems at a '17 for 1 C$' rate. Now they are recent items, but since the event is over, I now view them as "retired". They will never be released again. I personally value my recently retired items at a '4 for 1C$' rate. This would bump you up to around an 64C$ offer.

TL;DR
I feel like with the bulk amount of items they're asking for, 15 C$ may be a little on the low side.
But again, that's the opinion of someone who tends to covet items more than pets in retrospect- me.
(●´ω｀●)

thank you! could I possible get a 2nd opinion before I edit the trade?

[andreá]

ooo
how is this for ur peas <3?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121329&userid=673904&signature=UnMZGqJrb6KMiPXQfSzm7Q is this fair?

You were answered on the previous page.
I agree that it’s unfair to you.

[sycamore.]

ooo
how is this for ur peas <3?

I would personally accept! I’ve seen the UR peas go for around 1-2 sorbets. The pink balloon is well under a sorbet, and although the August PPS is high demand, it doesn’t fetch THAT much to fill the gap. I could be wrong though, so get some more opinions ^^

[.dylan.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121329&userid=673904&signature=UnMZGqJrb6KMiPXQfSzm7Q is this fair?

Unfair to you.
Their side is worth about 2 mid Advents, maybe 2 mid and 1 low, and your side is worth 6 mid Advents.

cool thank you very much!

[popping star]

ooo
how is this for ur peas <3?

I would personally accept! I’ve seen the UR peas go for around 1-2 sorbets. The pink balloon is well under a sorbet, and although the August PPS is high demand, it doesn’t fetch THAT much to fill the gap. I could be wrong though, so get some more opinions ^^

Agreed.
A balloon dog is only 1/4th of a sorbet.
The August pps has high demand, but it won’t fill in the gap ranging from a red toxic to a purple toxic + red rose pps.

[Swerenity]

Fair? I value bmd at sorbet.