The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lopez]

How fair is this?
Thanks in advance :0

[flora]

xxx was this trade really bad for me, even considering that the july pps has "bad" demand? ;n; would like to know for future reference and to learn from it.

[ewetwo]

Is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76112484&userid=728703&signature=8r6eqiNTzsG_e5k6xXnjcQ

Thanks in advance!

[nobxdy]

xxx was this trade really bad for me, even considering that the july pps has "bad" demand? ;n; would like to know for future reference and to learn from it.

I believe you've been answered on this trade before.

The UR Bee and July PPS are on the same tier, so rarity wise they would be fine for each other.
Demand wise, I've seen the July PPS go for its worth, and the UR Bee typically fetches its worth as well.
I value the July PPS and UR Bee at its worth, so if you do too then you were slightly overpaying with the Nonballoon.

It honestly just depends on where you value the pets involved. ^^

Is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76112484&userid=728703&signature=8r6eqiNTzsG_e5k6xXnjcQ

Thanks in advance!

It's unfair to you. Your rare dog is from 2009, their side is not worth a 2009 rare. ^^

[in act ive]

.

[cyanic]

how does this look, thank you to anyone who helps!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76110970&userid=616959&signature=jjPI5ksQYE-KeKUWFkZTSg

[nobxdy]

.

It was unfair to you. Your Nick Cake Dog is worth 6-7 '09 rares, their side is only worth 3 '09 rares/about a Tier 1 Advent list. ^^

how does this look, thank you to anyone who helps!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76110970&userid=616959&signature=jjPI5ksQYE-KeKUWFkZTSg

Their rare dog was extended into mid-late 2009 (originally from 2008), so they're overpaying. Your cat was also extended into April 2010.

Demand is up to you, and if you're happy with this or not. ^^

[in act ive]

.

It was unfair to you. Your Nick Cake Dog is worth 6-7 '09 rares, their side is only worth 3 '09 rares/about a Tier 1 Advent list. ^^

(With that being said, this would be overpay as well? I feel dumb because if that's over, then this is obviously way over... Maybe the cake dog would be fair?

[nobxdy]

-snip-

(With that being said, this would be overpay as well? I feel dumb because if that's over, then this is obviously way over... Maybe the cake dog would be fair?

Yes, you'd still be overpaying.
Your side is worth a September List / Light Leopard tier, their side is still only worth about a Tier 1 / Tier 2 Advent List.

Demand is really up to you and your trading partner. If you're both happy with the trade, then it's fair. (:

[Fishrabies]

hey, I was wondering if this was fair demand and rarity wise...
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76112881&userid=812148&signature=vfADc1OtNKeWL9vHxJPChA