The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[lemonishin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960107&userid=774851&signature=xXWCnTLWekxLfH_YCfAlZw

i dont know what shima goes for but

would you do it?

I'm the other one In the trade seeing if it's fair too !

[popping star]

Opinions on this bid?
I personally love it as cake dogs are my favorite lists!
I just want to know if it's overall a great trade. ^^

[mynameisbacon]

Fair? I know the shima is high demand but... idk
Also, does anybody know some stuff that people who really want the shima would give for it?

Here's the trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960038&userid=936315&signature=nC93Seo1QUUuRHjKAw2L1A

[popping star]

Opinions on this bid?
I personally love it as cake dogs are my favorite lists!
I just want to know if it's overall a great trade. ^^

[HALCYONDAZE]

Ia this trade fair?

[popping star]

Ia this trade fair?

Rarity wise, it's unfair to the UR aussie as it's worth 1 non and 1 sorbet.
Demand is up to you.
The aussie typically fetches a non, however, so this could be considered fair even with the advent on your side.

[Skóll]

Could I get some help for this trade here. If it's not fair what can be added or removed? Thank you so much for the help

[Demonking Urizen]

Could I get some help for this trade here. If it's not fair what can be added or removed? Thank you so much for the help

Unfair to you, by 1 - 3 '10 uncommons (depends on how many uncommons you value for a rare of the same year)

[Miss Biscuit~]

Could I get some help for this trade here. If it's not fair what can be added or removed? Thank you so much for the help

The ‘10 side needs to add about 3 more ‘10 uncommons for it to be fair for your ‘09 rare.

[Demonking Urizen]

Fair? I know the shima is high demand but... idk
Also, does anybody know some stuff that people who really want the shima would give for it?

Here's the trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960038&userid=936315&signature=nC93Seo1QUUuRHjKAw2L1A

Unfair to you.
The Shima usually goes for a mid advent; your side adds up to a low September.