The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[AnimalL0ver100]

This is an auction and these are some bids. Advice please?
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75834598&userid=918929&signature=9yNEtI6K-B6Tl2TV_Cysyw
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75834973&userid=918929&signature=kE755AgoHxvD12O0IgSeAA
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75843951&userid=918929&signature=xGiKFeGvL-t43isDYHlMGQ

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75844669&userid=918929&signature=DLEkIyeZHDA7Y8F5SfBXXg
What is the worth of the items?

[swallows]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75844443&userid=293211&signature=e2BqEaRWCe4w1Xjw3EucUA

Is this fair? If not what needs to be added and to which side?
Thank you for any help
*I know they cancelled, but I’d still like to know if it was fair.

[Meow :3]

Please help quickly! Is this fair?

[. faded .]

i still need help on this, rarity and demand wise. I think they're overpaying but I don't know about the demand of birthday pets. I hate to leave them waiting.

view trade

[zero.two]

1. Bid 1 6/10
2. Bid 2

might i get a bid for 2? if 5/10 is just fair thank you!

i'd say 4/10 - your store is worth an early 09' and they have a late 09' and a late '10, I don't think the unknowns add very much

i still need help on this, rarity and demand wise. I think they're overpaying but I don't know about the demand of birthday pets. I hate to leave them waiting.

view trade

They're overpaying. Demand for that pet isn't really anything from what i've seen, it goes for fair trades

[sumatra.]

Thoughts on this and this?

[Lothlórien]

Which one of these is best? I have the Cookie Dog, Holly Dog & Christmas Dog. Hoping to get opinions for both demand and rarity.
Thanks!

1

2

3

4

dillydally

[the.kitsune.prince]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75843481&userid=120238&signature=Qh5CaAEw0FeUp9vIUtt7ww

Any help with this one? Thank you in advancee

[This Is Halloween]

help quick? fair for their grinner? Am I overpaying by the 09 rare?

[swallows]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75844443&userid=293211&signature=e2BqEaRWCe4w1Xjw3EucUA

Is this fair? If not what needs to be added and to which side?
Thank you for any help
*I know they cancelled, but I’d still like to know if it was fair.