The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Self Made]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73610506&userid=503946&signature=ku29nHvG6_M0avW_ryydAA

[Lillysong]

How fair is this trade?

Unfair.

Agreed. The rare is worth a 2016 uncommon.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73611056&userid=710778&signature=-fTBfNJvtq_LURF8Pacm5g

How about this?

Rarity wise, its unfair to you by one rat. Though its up to you and your partner if the extra makes up for demand.

[Snowdown]

Link
How about this?

[Roses & Gold]

Hello! Can anyone please tell me if this is fair or not?
A HUGE thank you to anyone who helps! ❤

Rarity wise, the store pets would've payed for themselves. (3 month rule)

Demand wise, both the store pets have a fair demand, so this trade was mostly personal preference of how you and your partner value the store pets. (Personal Preference)

The store pet for store pet is enough alone ♡♡ (3 Month rule)

[FOUND VERDICT]

Link
How about this?

quite unfair to you.
their dog is worth an '09 rare + '10 rare

it does have good demand though, so it can fetch some overpay. i personally haven't seen in go for more than 2 '09 rares though

[Roses & Gold]

What do you guys think of this trade? I'm quite aware that it's overpay,
just wondering if you personally would take it. Thank you so much in advance! <3

I would not just because of personal preference, I like the colors and design of the galaxies and really dislike how the UR aussie looks. If they were offering a phoenix (same tier) instead I would take it.
It's a really nice offer and it's overpay by over a sorbet, but in the end personal preference matters more for me!

Still looking for a few more opinions, thank you so much for your input though!

I agree with the above reply ^

[Lillysong]

Would a cakedog be fair for these guys? Given demand.
If not, what would be fair?

[TheKwakiutlTribe]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73611056&userid=710778&signature=-fTBfNJvtq_LURF8Pacm5g

How about this?

[ziferblat]

should i do this for a sunback?
i was thinking about adding a few advents but im not sure.

[Clayflower.]

Could I get some help with these? Thanks to anyone who can offer their opinion! c:

Trade 1

Trade 2