The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[mmmrro]

Hiya! I’m not good with items, can anyone tell me How to make this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73504183&userid=80889&signature=YVaa1Jy6rjl4XY5NzVaJsQ

[nobxdy]

Is This a Good Trade Up?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432284&userid=919360&signature=bYcT_MAPqFUp-vm35hADog

Is This Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73498577&userid=919360&signature=r9wrdSeOdOjN8xd50HmVXA

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73503705&userid=919360&signature=r-8MjLXDYTctWOZ39TF_4A

1. It's fair. Blue Rose (7 MA) + Nonballoon (35 MA) = Green Toxic (42 MA)
It depends on whether you want to trade up or not. (:

2. Nonballoon = 620C$
UR Apple = 455C$
455+200 = 655C$, so it's overpay (i'm pretty sure that's how C$ works, if not then please correct this)

3. It's unfair to the Nick Sunback. The Nick Sunback is worth 2 '09 rares, your side is worth 1.5 '09 rares. (:

[kaplantai]

I'm not very good with item vs. pet rarity, so would this be considered fair?

Thank you in advance to anyone who offers their assistance or opinion. <3

Similarly, would either of these four trades be considered fair? Any advice on pet for item trades? (I'm starting to desperately wish there was a more accurate listing of item values to make researching this easier :< )

Thank you in advance FTT <3 I appreciate the help!

the first trade is very unfair to you. the angel wings alone are worth a rare to very rare from october to november of 2008. the next trade is unfair by a lot as well, the malk staff plushie alone is worth an early 09' rare or very rare. the third, the other side is overpaying. the yellow dog is a tier 5 advent list. the other 2 trades seem to be fair though.

[kaplantai]

is this fair for me?
boop
thanks for any help!!

[Ki-Mono]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73504483&userid=92093&signature=CryFJFM2Boz-OTycM6H4SQ
fair or nah?

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

It's fair. A 2018 rare is worth a 2016 uncommon or a 2015 common. (Guide I used is this one.)

Thanks! Can I get another opinion?

[sumatra.]

Is this trade fair?

It's fair. A 2018 rare is worth a 2016 uncommon or a 2015 common. (Guide I used is this one.)

Thanks! Can I get another opinion?

I also agree. The math is correct as a 2017 rare is indeed worth a ‘16 uncommon. While a ‘16 uncommon is worth a ‘15 common!

[nightmare eyes!]

Warning: Bulk

Is this fair? Thanks so much in advance!

[Sad_Boi]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73506599&userid=933447&signature=UWILO--grGQIvicHo0ndVA

Fair?^

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73506599&userid=933447&signature=UWILO--grGQIvicHo0ndVA

Fair?^

Very unfair to you, they need to add at least a sorbet