The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Michael's Fan.]

Would this be?

[Snowlondon]

Ik it's canceled, but was this fair?

Edited, sorry

still looks like the wrong link :O

You sure?

[Paper Moon]

I'm not very good with item vs. pet rarity, so would this be considered fair?

Thank you in advance to anyone who offers their assistance or opinion. <3

[the]

Is This a Good Trade Up?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432284&userid=919360&signature=bYcT_MAPqFUp-vm35hADog

Is This Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73498577&userid=919360&signature=r9wrdSeOdOjN8xd50HmVXA

~

Would this be?

The Pocky Is Worth a Pet From Christmas 2008 And The '13 Store Pet = Early '09 Rare So That's Overpay.

The Items On The Store Pet Side:
Nonjewel Plushie - Christmas 2009
Eros Fairy - Valentine's Day 2010

Over All, The Pocky Is Overpay For All The Things On The Store Pet Side And The Items On That Side

I disagree.
Pocky = rare/very rare '08
'13 store pet = rare '09
Eros & plushie are worth a rare/very rare '09 each
Together their side is worth 3-5 rares '09, while the pocky is worth 1.5-2.5 rares '09.

[Viozel]

Ik it's canceled, but was this fair?

their side looks to be about 22 mid Advents,
and as the nons are worth 248-252, this was very unfair to you.

[jsnprodmusic]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73502284&userid=936688&signature=xhO0hvvM4T5L9K7AjgIpnw

fair?need to know ASAP


oh..ok just ignore it

[axelandria]

can anyone help? is this trade fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73499548&userid=756309&signature=pjC83lyQ4zWbVZiaV0-q9Q

[Horror]

can anyone help? is this trade fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73499548&userid=756309&signature=pjC83lyQ4zWbVZiaV0-q9Q

Their rare alone is overpay as it's an early 09 rare and yours is late

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

[Firefoxx01]

In relation to the message below, is this fair?

?
Thanks in advance!

Unfair to the Foxen set.
Foxen Set = Halloween 2013 = 1 2013 Uncommon each
1 2013 Uncommon = 3-4 C$

The C$ side would have to add roughly 4 C$ more to make it fair.

*This is solely based on rarity and has not taken into account any demand the items may have

Thanks in advance!