The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[jsnprodmusic]

QUESTION: How many 2018-2016 commons can i get for a 2018 store pet? thanks!

[Firefoxx01]

In relation to the message below, is this fair?

?
Thanks in advance!

Unfair to the Foxen set.
Foxen Set = Halloween 2013 = 1 2013 Uncommon each
1 2013 Uncommon = 3-4 C$

The C$ side would have to add roughly 4 C$ more to make it fair.

*This is solely based on rarity and has not taken into account any demand the items may have

Thanks in advance!

[Kindess]

[CONTENT DELETED]

[I'm Grey]

QUESTION: How many 2018-2016 commons can i get for a 2018 store pet? thanks!

Valuing a rare at 8 commons:

512 2016 commons
1,024 2017 commons
2,048 2018 commons

*Lots of people value bulk higher than it’s technical worth; I personally wouldn’t expect to get a fair trade.

[Soundgarden]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73499946&userid=811281&signature=g_dEKReiKACckSz4LBfV-w

How is this?

[popping star]

Is this fair demand wise? ×

Unfair to you even with demand.
The basilisk set tends to go for fair trades, and if they get overpay usually they only fetch a low-mid Sept. list.
Your list is a high September list.
(Info from here: x x)

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73499946&userid=811281&signature=g_dEKReiKACckSz4LBfV-w

How is this?

Unfair to you.
The purple sleipnir tends to fetch a mid-high advent with demand. (The brown one is the one that usually goes for main lists.)
Valuing it at tier 10 on the advent list, their side is worth 15-16 '09 rares + an '09 uncommon. That's only worth the grinner tier on the September list. (13-17 '09 rares.)

[. faded .]

1.trades/viewtrade.php?id=73500039&userid=938412&signature=OW0ojzcSKq5essa0YGNNTw

I don't know.

[Michael's Fan.]

Would this be?

[buzzy]

is this fair? should i accept, or edit?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73499854&userid=787060&signature=5HIG9N61nrVhCwRZV5dUJQ

[Asvoria]

A Lime Ice Rat for my Malk Dragons?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73499974&userid=242662&signature=qn0CZaOZNgJ3o_ZzFlEmiw

Thanks for any help!