The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Horror]

hello! This trade has already been cancelled but is this fair? What would I have to add? I'm not very experienced with list pets

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73483869&userid=878037&signature=Ua-Us0tyvyUcWGOOKsP26Q

Unfair to them by roughly a low advent list by rarity, or more if you happen to value the rat at less than it's worth

[ooo]

Are Any Of These Fair?

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432710&userid=919360&signature=I4uMYPQlfi9YP3g-Xoqh3g
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73481286&userid=919360&signature=giackscxl6F4nCdfLZW8MA
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73490205&userid=919360&signature=GwXs_1mziK5EwHHCvpt0xw
4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432284&userid=919360&signature=bYcT_MAPqFUp-vm35hADog

5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73490236&userid=919360&signature=E-jyBWJKB4JoCU8C_0LFTQ
I Know I'm Overpaying But They Value Their Cheshire Cat At a High September List

(#1) I wouldn’t accept this, From personal experience, C$ is extremely hard to trade for other lists, as no one really wants C$ for list pets. Unless you have the patience to find a trading partner who wants C$ for lists, this probably won’t be the best option in terms of profiting.

(#5) Demand of the Cheshire varies by user and there is absolutely no set demand for them. Often they’ll go for mid advents, however I have been offered grinners for mine and I traded my Cheshire eventually for a cake dog on the September list. I don’t believe the Cheshire could fetch anywhere close to this much though, this is pretty big overlay on your side.

(#3)
Dark Leapord=9 Mid Advents
Blue Rose=7 Mid Advents
Bun=1 Mid advent
Unfair to the dark Leapord.
(Not speaking for myself but this was stated above)

[UniqueTrash]

Bid 1
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 7

These are some of the better bids of my auction. Could I get some opinions?

[osamu]

Second Opinions?

[Skóll]

I need help with these two offers. Which one is the best to take?
1.trades/viewtrade.php?id=73489467&userid=142192&signature=7X7-Ceq35uCpTe8bcMQApw
Or
2.trades/viewtrade.php?id=73486901&userid=142192&signature=wCVxW6AjKvmi_HfWtcF-ow
Thank you so much for the help.

[osamu]

Second Opinions?

Oh and this? I'm terrible with items

[MiniMazarine]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73487113&userid=819108&signature=TRupytjFHSNb_uDxpI66IQ hELP

This too trades/viewtrade.php?id=73490300&userid=819108&signature=Z0Jb_E2CXHWe2gIlWo6Q_A

[Galaxy_Stitch]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73490547&userid=928172&signature=eEz5uHahjXs1SMLMmBcP1A
this fair??

[pigeon -]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73487113&userid=819108&signature=TRupytjFHSNb_uDxpI66IQ hELP

This too trades/viewtrade.php?id=73490300&userid=819108&signature=Z0Jb_E2CXHWe2gIlWo6Q_A

both are hugely unfair to you, even though your very rare is dated 2011,
it's a re-release of a main list pet so worth a whole lot more than normal rares c:

[ooo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73487113&userid=819108&signature=TRupytjFHSNb_uDxpI66IQ hELP

This too trades/viewtrade.php?id=73490300&userid=819108&signature=Z0Jb_E2CXHWe2gIlWo6Q_A

These are both very unfair to you, the skeleton PPS is on the main list, their side adds up to about a low advent on both.