The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[skelliursa]

xxx
Large quantity warning

Can anyone help me with this ? I'm not entirely sure what my side is worth..
There's a lot to figure up. ; ; & I know quantity has a value of it's own.
So I'd really like some opinions on this.
Thanks in advance for any help ! =)

[2014--Pets]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73418087&userid=678613&signature=yHdNvLF611Gye0lsC3xZvA

Can someone please tell me how fair or unfair this trade is? I've posted before but no one has answered. Please and thank you!

[KikisDelivery97]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73468961&userid=70652&signature=2tH6dwGTB9w86yhcf9FFLg

This bid on my cinnabun? Thanks for any help!


Also would I be crazy not to take this? The only reason Im hesitating is because its an apple and I just spent a long time building up my hamster collection and would have to start all over again. Just HOW bad is the demand on the apple?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73469012&userid=70652&signature=Xi32z2yrhpQ9mGoyVPIO7g

[plisetsky]

a lil help, please?? thanks in advance <3

The shima longtail is really only an ‘09 rare. With demand, they’re worth low-mid advents, so this would be okay, however I’ve seen the shima fetch all the way up to a purple bat dog which is high on the September list. The demand varies by person, so It’s up to you if you want to accept or wait for another offer.

i see, thank you sm!

help with this, please? ( warning ; image heavy )

[LuvFinnick123]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73464009&userid=335581&signature=fp-yNJQjU5eqRiqS-qjIxw
Is this fair? Thank you ❤️❤️

[kee;]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73464009&userid=335581&signature=fp-yNJQjU5eqRiqS-qjIxw
Is this fair? Thank you ❤️❤️

It depends on how you value your bmd.
Obviously, according to rarity it’s unfair to the toxic.
With demand, I’ve seen the bmd pretty consistently go for around a balloon dog. If this is where you value the bmd, it would be unfair to the toxic.
Some users may also value your bmd higher because it’s true date. This could then, possibly, depending on your personal evaluation, elevate the bmd from balloon dog area to the green toxic.
No matter how you value it considering the demand if the bmd, the fact that it’s true date, etc. it all comes down to how you and your trading partner value the pets involved.

-kee

[tigerclaw]

are either of these fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=72017981&userid=875006&signature=EXR3t3DI_ziqT-w0GvBlsQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=72157254&userid=875006&signature=b-kRjjzsOWROIMKr-LKiNA

I need help with these.

[Yin Yang.]

Fair?

[Animall]

May I have personal opinions on whether or not you would accept this trade? I value the eat me/drink me at 3 nons.

If you value the set at 3 nons then it wouldn't be fair for you because I believe the Red cerb (Demand wise) is worth 2 nons, depends how you value the pets, but I value the eat me and drink me at 2 nons (demand wise) but the extras don't make up 3 nons

Thanks! Second opinion?
I don’t quite know the demand of the red cerb. I know it’s high, but...

[Yin Yang.]

Fair?