The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[popping star]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73448743&userid=938412&signature=2KeK-ZJEzOXa7YrBWKfWxQ
It was a trade I sent but I joined yesterday so I don't know everything about CS but please tell me if it was fair or not. Thank you

It was very unfair to the C$ side.
Your side is only worth around 5-9 C$. (I got the C$ values from here.)

[Sad_Boi]

Would a Tier 1 Advent + a Tier 5 Advent = a Tier 10 Advent? if not then what would it equal?

The advents together would be worth 9-11 '09 rares.
9 '09 rares equals to tier 9, and 11 '09 rares would be slightly more than tier 10.
It's pretty fair for a tier 10 advent if you value the two advents at 10-11 '09 rares.

Thanks again!

[. faded .]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73448743&userid=938412&signature=2KeK-ZJEzOXa7YrBWKfWxQ
It was a trade I sent but I joined yesterday so I don't know everything about CS but please tell me if it was fair or not. Thank you

It was very unfair to the C$ side.
Your side is only worth around 5-9 C$. (I got the C$ values from here.)

Okay thank you very much

[Clawdina]

would this be fair? ;

depends on where you value the skelebun. I believe the average value based on what the trade offers are in the rares list thread would be at least 4 nons so this would be unfair to you even with valuing each pet on their side at their full value

[ZenitsuAgatsuma]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432222&userid=919360&signature=kGczDNRqxlXqmTBcA-kawQ

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432710&userid=919360&signature=I4uMYPQlfi9YP3g-Xoqh3g

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73433810&userid=919360&signature=i4K_8-Ww9vVQKYagOlgDKQ

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73439737&userid=919360&signature=mRSrN9ANSzgfUCqgTnryhg

5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73443735&userid=919360&signature=gnwR8gKLKx8pmncwej2NoQ

6. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73443823&userid=919360&signature=RzPXwDKnMUXrJ98N4UauXw

Fair?

1: not sure
2:not sure
3 looks pretty fair
4 VERY UNFAIR TO YOU
5 your side is worth more
6 not sure

[popping star]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432222&userid=919360&signature=kGczDNRqxlXqmTBcA-kawQ

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73432710&userid=919360&signature=I4uMYPQlfi9YP3g-Xoqh3g

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73433810&userid=919360&signature=i4K_8-Ww9vVQKYagOlgDKQ

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73439737&userid=919360&signature=mRSrN9ANSzgfUCqgTnryhg

5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73443735&userid=919360&signature=gnwR8gKLKx8pmncwej2NoQ

6. trades/viewtrade.php?id=73443823&userid=919360&signature=RzPXwDKnMUXrJ98N4UauXw

Fair?

1: not sure
2:not sure
3 looks pretty fair
4 VERY UNFAIR TO YOU
5 your side is worth more
6 not sure

Trade 3 is actually unfair to the uncommon.
A 2018 rare is worth around a 2016 uncommon, not a 2013 uncommon. (I got that value from here.)

Trade 5 also looks unfair to the 2009 rare.
A 2009 rare is worth 128 '16 rares = 256 '17 rares = 512 '18 rares.
The quantity side has 6 '16 rares, 21 '17 rares, and 13 '18 rares. That equals to roughly 19 '16 rares.

[2014--Pets]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73418087&userid=678613&signature=yHdNvLF611Gye0lsC3xZvA

Is this fair? I think they are asking for too many pets. (This is an edited version of an earlier trade. If possible, could someone determine both?) Thank you!!

[Creepii_Crawlee]

Hiya! Just wondering if this seems fair to you guys trades/viewtrade.php?id=73448872&userid=906165&signature=kTOSW-4M4znrVsYnFYD7hg

[zillywair]

x x
how fair are these?

[kujoestar]

x x
how fair are these?

i wouldn't do either of them, they're unfair to you.