The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[bear]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73407630&userid=922002&signature=Gj74gKKRKKV5CvlEXwkI5w


Thanks a lot to anyone who helps! BTW, the cake dog is one of my faves!

No, it is very unfair to you! The cake dog is on the septembers list - none of their pets are on the rares list. At most their side is worth first tier advent list.

[FANTASIIIA]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73401916&userid=774851&signature=B_N1YxSaXzEg3sWlkswEKg

How much are they overpaying me? No idea if their pets are lists, I'm expecting more than 2 '09 rares for the cancer since It's what I paid for it, and the dragons have nice demand and I'm sure they can go for something nice.

[Zombilon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73401916&userid=774851&signature=B_N1YxSaXzEg3sWlkswEKg

How much are they overpaying me? No idea if their pets are lists, I'm expecting more than 2 '09 rares for the cancer since It's what I paid for it, and the dragons have nice demand and I'm sure they can go for something nice.

The zodiacs are a fair swap.
The other pets aren't lists, but the dog is from October 2008, and the cat is from February 2009. They're overpaying by a lot considering your store dragons are only worth a mid 2010 rare each. I would consider this the "something nice." ^^

[kee;]

Is this fair?

I would say it’s slightly unfair to them because of the dates.
Each of your items are from this year. I would value them at a 2018 common each, except for the animal egg which I would put at a 2018 uncommon. It isn’t very unfair though, so I wouldn’t worry about accepting if you’re interested in the trade.

-kee

[rinpun]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73409544&userid=811367&signature=pZgmGtdQoqSNEp7zOXHdLw
do these dates add up?? ty! ❤️

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

I need help please! Thank you for any help I can get c;
Also this please!
Snip

Strictly rarity wise I'd say that's pretty fair if you value the ur fox at its average value (1.5 nons)
Demand wise is up to you since I don't know where you value each pet ^^

Second opinion?

I agree, I also believe it’s fair [/quote]
Anyone else? (first trade got canceled)

[kujoestar]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73401810&userid=776776&signature=s8CXZR7Xb_SW_hkALM3w1Q

Please help!!

[Marley.&.Me]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73401810&userid=776776&signature=s8CXZR7Xb_SW_hkALM3w1Q

Please help!!

the UR Rat goes for a sorbet + red x pps.

[dear.chaton]

how about this trade?

[grim]

how about this trade?

Rarity wise the wolf pps is overpay alone. I’ve never saw a BA go for a non before, the most they usually fetch with demand is a sorbet. It looks very unfair to you.