The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

I know this isn't fair rarity wise, however, would you accept This?

I want to be able to trade up the lists, and don't want to be set back. I know rats don't generally have good demand. So any and all opinions are appreciated!

seeairruhstradequestions <using to track, please do not delete. <3

[halloween.egg]

Was this fair? If not, I don't really mind, I'm just curious to find out. I'm bad at bulk trades, despite the fact that I regularly trade bulk for rats haha. Thanks in advance to anyone who can help!

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

I know this isn't fair rarity wise, however, would you accept This?

I want to be able to trade up the lists, and don't want to be set back. I know rats don't generally have good demand. So any and all opinions are appreciated!

seeairruhstradequestions <using to track, please do not delete. <3

[manhunt]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73179329&userid=649208&signature=KaPZi7DPFQp65jiPGw3wAg
is this fair?

[heartfades]

Hey again guys! How does this seem and what can I do to make it a fair trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73180925&userid=158024&signature=RWjxkbHwNX8UuJFOS5n1og

[StrawBenny]

which trade is better, help!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73180714&userid=754287&signature=fD4hq8COpdEuiBBDxXPRvw
or
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73180886&userid=754287&signature=o3-eBlMonFBQZDTpjIxrkw

[popping star]

which trade is better, help!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73180714&userid=754287&signature=fD4hq8COpdEuiBBDxXPRvw
or
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73180886&userid=754287&signature=o3-eBlMonFBQZDTpjIxrkw

Both trades are fair, however the second trade is worth more.
The second trade has a 2010 rare + add. The first trade only has a 2010 rare, so I'd go with the second trade.

[Bellarocks123a]

I need some opinions on this trade. Usually I only trade doubles, which is not inclusive of this pet, but it seems like a rather big overpay? I'm just not sure demand-wise, plus this was a store pet I believe so I'm not sure how that affects it's worth. Thanks in advance <3

2013 store pets are worth an early '09 rare.
Their side equals to 1 '09 rare + 1 '10 rare and some small add, so they are overpaying.
It's up to you whether you'd like to take this.

Thank you <3

Might I get a second opinion? I know when I got this there was a lot of demand for the llama so I just wanna check

[wingsofsilver]

Hello!

Is this trade fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73173797&userid=309172&signature=a7hdShyN8UTVILank-5HcA

[zillywair]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73174672&userid=932854&signature=MmpeuX4m1nNpdGM-sfkWMQ
im fairly certain this isnt fair, since store pets are worth a lot more, but can i get any help with what i should add/remove ??

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73180087&userid=932854&signature=HANKetD8rJWysrg3rsUnZg
and can i get help with this one too ??? thanks !!