The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167428&userid=641429&signature=eTZCHVre_pcrwMHZZdrTHg
?

They're overpaying. Their side is worth 4-5 '09 rares, your side is only worth 2 '09 rares.

Are you sure? I've been constantly getting trades for these two with 2 09 vrs and 10 rs and such. Are you talking about rarity wise in general or demand?

I'm talking rarity wise. Demand is up to you, and how you personally value the kitsunes. No one can give you a set worth with demand, because demand is user-based.

[Parasoul]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167428&userid=641429&signature=eTZCHVre_pcrwMHZZdrTHg
?

They're overpaying. Their side is worth 4-5 '09 rares, your side is only worth 2 '09 rares.

I'm talking rarity wise. Demand is up to you, and how you personally value the kitsunes. No one can give you a set worth with demand, because demand is user-based.

Alright, thank you for your input! can I get a second opinion too?

[Check the PO Box]

This person is offering 100 Chicken Dollars for one of my lists and at this point I don't really
know what they're worth so does anyone know if that's fair for any of the pets they added?

[Horror]

This person is offering 100 Chicken Dollars for one of my lists and at this point I don't really
know what they're worth so does anyone know if that's fair for any of the pets they added?

The C$ would be overpay for any one of the pets on your side except the scarf PPS, which is a sept list
100C$ is a top tier advent list, and all of your pets are mid or low advents or the non List pet (the 09 July vr white wolf isn't a list)

There is also a C$ thread here to check what your pet's are worth

[ATTERMON]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167532&userid=926449&signature=iROF8qTNRztxyxQ0eSA36w ?
i d o n ' t k n o w

[TyrannosaurusWreck]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73160278&userid=936257&signature=zeMLc99zqtvzxypRO0b-Rg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73160380&userid=936257&signature=lKz8EK8NpSZ83UdBel9vZg

are these overtrading or undertrading?? if its overtrading why isnt anyone accepting? please help
what should i add to get people to accept??

[Fertseshoy Getes]

Hello! What need to be added? Thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167854&userid=858381&signature=ywlMxIs1roVFOMRnLNFMqw

[skelliursa]

xxx

Could I have some help on this trade please ?

[spiderkisser]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73168544&userid=916942&signature=Vit86MjlqGLkZXzA6r1Q7Q
Not sure about this??
Datewise I think it would be unfair to me but the demand for the zodiacs must be pretty good, so I don't know..
I'm ok with overpaying a bit since this person is a collector & only has one of these, and this is one of my major dreamies

[lucky333123]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73168544&userid=916942&signature=Vit86MjlqGLkZXzA6r1Q7Q
Not sure about this??
Datewise I think it would be unfair to me but the demand for the zodiacs must be pretty good, so I don't know..
I'm ok with overpaying a bit since this person is a collector & only has one of these, and this is one of my major dreamies

It is actually fair due to the 3 month rule.

xxx

Could I have some help on this trade please ?

Personally I wouldn’t take it. The halo on the item guide was looked over in November 2016 thus it has been 2 years and items aren’t rereleased. If we go by the 2016 value each one is worth a mid-September list which is worth I would say 5 midadvents thus the halos alone are worth 15 midadvents. The pocky could go for a couple ‘09 rares each. Due to the amount of quantity of the items that are rare, I would say it is unfair to you.