The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Jacob]

Hi! Can I get some help? Can I have rarity and demand answered separately?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73163262&userid=884168&signature=tj2g7kH-ZvFbBMyhHRp2Rg
Thank you<3

please dont give false advice. the ba is worth around a sorbet with demand. it is extremely unfair to the ba

They weren't giving false advice. The BA is on the september list and only trades for a sorb+ because of demand, not rarity, and they were giving rarity worth, not demand.

To add on top of that if we were willing basing it on rarity the BA should realistically be put with its other tier 7 littermates but when the list was originally being put together they based it on both rarity and demand. So pets like the BMD and BA were put higher due to demand.

[ɖɛɱơŋıƈ • ℘ơʂʂɛʂʂıơŋ]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73154400&userid=342304&signature=xsh-U5qv9dra2DmqdlrWeg

Haven't traded C$ is a long time so I'm not too sure on it any more, any help is greatly appreciated, thank you!

I'm on the other end and would like to know

[Horror]

Hi! Can I get some help? Can I have rarity and demand answered separately?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73163262&userid=884168&signature=tj2g7kH-ZvFbBMyhHRp2Rg
Thank you<3

I can't really tell about demand, but I can figure out the rarity part for you.
The BA is worth 9 mid advents. The purple batdog is 6.5 mid advents. The other pets on your side add up to a bit less than a mid advent, so You'd be short by roughly a mid and a low advent (:

please dont give false advice. the ba is worth around a sorbet with demand. it is extremely unfair to the ba

The BA is technically worth the same as it's litter mates. "Demand" got it moved up to a high sept so list wise it's already placed higher than it's supposed to be anyways, and people still just overpay even more than that. It's not worth anything close to a sorb. Worth =/= demand/value

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73163298&userid=918765&signature=1y-AdxWoj3-sJ4q8YMIA6Q

would this be fair?

they are overpaying demand wise and rairity wise. the brow sleipneir goes for around a low to mid mainlist. they are offering you a non and add

They're offering the worth of 2 sorbs, not a non. The malk might go up to a non with "demand" sometimes but demand doesn't actually make a pet worth any more.
Either way they still overpaid, I only value the sliepnir at a nonballoon at most (low-mid main as said above).

[gudetama]

ur peas = ur malk?

please help!

also sorry for all the mistakes i made previously.

[FOUND VERDICT]

ur peas = ur malk?

please help!

also sorry for all the mistakes i made previously.

demandwise the ur malk goes for an non, the ur peas for 1-2 sorbets from what i've seen.

[DarknessANDLight]

I sent this trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73163470&userid=926207&signature=GNjeYeBoCTrdzGXrbwCyow
Is it fair?

[MunchiiMoon]

?

[The Last Raven]

?

Very unfair to you due to date gap

[Parasoul]

quick response please? if not, could someone tell me what this cat is worth?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73163627&userid=641429&signature=NHW4TyDYxMAW5T1rP5la1g

[Sad_Boi]

quick response please? if not, could someone tell me what this cat is worth?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73163627&userid=641429&signature=NHW4TyDYxMAW5T1rP5la1g

warrior cats usally go for a 2010 rare and rarely an 09. id personally accept since I'm pretty sure the cat is an 09 re-release and so that alone would be alright. ( I'm trynna say they are overpaying) Please get second opinions as this is just my own! Good luck!