The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Zombilon]

Would you personally accept this?
Just based on demand, needing opinions, no need to calculate fairness. (I love my true-date 7th tiers, but I also love the PPS Dragon Cats, so this is a tough choice).

Personally I wouldn't accept, if the PPS dragon cat traded for tier 7s, they would have set it offering the cats alone, at least that'd be my thinking if I got the trade. The two tier 2 wood dogs are worth 3-4 rares each and so are worth one of the tier 7s. If you're particularly attached to your dogs, perhaps half the pets on both side? 2 of your dogs for 1 of their dark wood dogs and 2 dragon cats?

Thanks, second opinions? ^^

[DarknessANDLight]

Which one should I take?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73117364&userid=926207&signature=8tep4bebREIGoTy6Cx-yXg
or
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73098444&userid=926207&signature=eptFssDqw4hL_zH9UemPbg
thanks

[Jedi Master Lady Ren]

Is This fair?

[acely86]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73144394&userid=933291&signature=-UB4fFkybOc0ahHzuck_gA

How do I make this trade fair? I don't have anything uft thats on their wishlist either

Edit: same with this one trades/viewtrade.php?id=73144701&userid=933291&signature=--5-fgzDRsjVHjM1xMLJWw

[EchothroughDarkness]

is this trade fair??

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73145092&userid=410864&signature=HwcxP8cCLQ0EpH3Kr7roUA

[Tara_Markov]

I feel like this is extremely unfair to me, especially since the dog is a 2009 re-release. Can I get a second opinion?

Thanks!

[Zombilon]

I feel like this is extremely unfair to me, especially since the dog is a 2009 re-release. Can I get a second opinion?

Thanks!

Yes, it's extremely unfair to you. Their side doesn't even add up to a 2013 rare.

[Tara_Markov]

I feel like this is extremely unfair to me, especially since the dog is a 2009 re-release. Can I get a second opinion?

Thanks!

Yes, it's extremely unfair to you. Their side doesn't even add up to a 2013 rare.

Thanks!

[Zombilon]

Would you personally accept this?
Just based on demand, needing opinions, no need to calculate fairness. (I love my true-date 7th tiers, but I also love the PPS Dragon Cats, so this is a tough choice).

Personally I wouldn't accept, if the PPS dragon cat traded for tier 7s, they would have set it offering the cats alone, at least that'd be my thinking if I got the trade. The two tier 2 wood dogs are worth 3-4 rares each and so are worth one of the tier 7s. If you're particularly attached to your dogs, perhaps half the pets on both side? 2 of your dogs for 1 of their dark wood dogs and 2 dragon cats?

Thanks, second opinions? ^^

[Pura]

Thoughts on this? I am really in the dark on item values anymore; I know that those are shop dogs but I'm not terribly interested in them from a collection standpoint, are they in any sort of demand I could flip?