The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Kabuski]

There's a Cake Dog AND A peppermint BWolf for my shima + fodder?

Should I accept or wait for more bids?

Is this worth more or less than a red rose?

The shima longtail is just a 2009 rare, it is not worth that much at all. I've heard it can trade for overpay and maybe advents, but this is really over.

The cake dog alone is worth more than a red rose.

This trade is was over on their part. Shima's with demand can maybe fetch a 7th tier on average (for what i've seen) i've had a couple before and for all of them I either got a 7th tier advent list or something equal to that value. Now, demand is user base so it just depends on who you traded.

The cake dog alone is on a September list.
They also did 6/7 09' rares which is worth a 7th tier advent list.

[kyeza]

I need a little help with this trade. Is it fair or should somebody add something?

[cloven]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73143454&userid=919435&signature=ZtnwCQKtDdg8q81Q5sEoHQ
Is this fair? It's the same tier

Edit: don't be spooked, it's only 1 for 1

Thanks for the tier info but how is demand?

[skyline]

i'm honestly stumped here, i don't want to deal with the bw's demand, but i'm unsure
if i could possibly benefit from it, as i don't know what it's going for, and if it can
get a non that easy. I value my ba at 2 sorbs, so i'm unsure if this'd be better to
take or not, cause i'm not sure what the bw is getting atm, i'd really appreciate
any opinions, thank you!!^^

[Kabuski]

I need a little help with this trade. Is it fair or should somebody add something?

Your dog is originally from 2009 which makes it worth 2 09 rares. The first is an extension from 2008 and the other is a re-release from 2009 (apart of the staff pet set)
so they're trade is over with the uncommon

[Dobyeu]

i'm honestly stumped here, i don't want to deal with the bw's demand, but i'm unsure
if i could possibly benefit from it, as i don't know what it's going for, and if it can
get a non that easy. I value my ba at 2 sorbs, so i'm unsure if this'd be better to
take or not, cause i'm not sure what the bw is getting atm, i'd really appreciate
any opinions, thank you!!^^

from what I've seen the BW due to demand goes for 1.5 nons - 2 nons. So it's overpay on their side.

[FOUND VERDICT]

i'm honestly stumped here, i don't want to deal with the bw's demand, but i'm unsure
if i could possibly benefit from it, as i don't know what it's going for, and if it can
get a non that easy. I value my ba at 2 sorbs, so i'm unsure if this'd be better to
take or not, cause i'm not sure what the bw is getting atm, i'd really appreciate
any opinions, thank you!!^^

from what I've seen the BW due to demand goes for 1.5 nons - 2 nons. So it's overpay on their side.

re-release black advents usually go for 2 sorbets (what you value it at), the bw should easily be able to fetch you 1.5 nons at lowest.
i personally got an dogtag for mine, so 3 nons worth

[cloven]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73144281&userid=919435&signature=R79ZmPS0SM6LK_0BHW1zlA

Is this okay?

[artemercy]

Is THIS fair? Thank you so much xx

[FOUND VERDICT]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73144281&userid=919435&signature=R79ZmPS0SM6LK_0BHW1zlA

Is this okay?

quite unfair to you.
the grinner is worth 15 - 17 '09 rares and goes for fair trades