The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[popping star]

Is this fair for my C$? (Warning: bulk trade.)

Seeing as the sunjewel goes for 1840, I would say extremely unfair to the C$. I could be wrong though, so get a second opinion.

Thank you! Second opinion?

[Joof]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73127777&userid=113942&signature=WWQoxZRvd_gvWkeNEOAuhg

Is this close to being fair?

A mid advent is worth 7-8 '09 rares. Currently the quantity side weighs in as 6 technically, but if you factor in the pretty good trade rate for the white feb and the fact that all of the '09s are early, it could possibly be fine. ^^ It's up to you personally whether or not to treat it as just an ordinary '09 and to add another '09. It's a pretty good trade.

Second opinion please?

[myth;]

i'm honestly stumped here, i don't want to deal with the bw's demand, but i'm unsure
if i could possibly benefit from it, as i don't know what it's going for, and if it can
get a non that easy. I value my ba at 2 sorbs, so i'm unsure if this'd be better to
take or not, cause i'm not sure what the bw is getting atm, i'd really appreciate
any opinions, thank you!!^^

I'm on the other side c:

It's extremely unfair to the UR Butterfly Wolf, that goes without question. Even if you did value the BA at a sorbet or even two (even though many will pay a sorbet for a re-released one at maximum), it's still unfair to the butterfly wolf. I have seen them go for more than a non, on one occasion it did fetch 3 nons, it just takes time and patience.

The butterfly wolf can trade for more than a sorbet, I really wouldn't trade it for a BA alone.

Is this fair for my C$? (Warning: bulk trade.)

Seeing as the sunjewel goes for 1840, I would say extremely unfair to the C$. I could be wrong though, so get a second opinion.

Thank you! Second opinion?

Agreed, even if the pet's individual values to go for that amount of C$ (which would take an age to calculate), I wouldn't trade that much C$ for non-main list pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73127777&userid=113942&signature=WWQoxZRvd_gvWkeNEOAuhg

Is this close to being fair?

A mid advent is worth 7-8 '09 rares. Currently the quantity side weighs in as 6 technically, but if you factor in the pretty good trade rate for the white feb and the fact that all of the '09s are early, it could possibly be fine. ^^ It's up to you personally whether or not to treat it as just an ordinary '09 and to add another '09. It's a pretty good trade.

Second opinion please?

Agreed with the above.

[aaliyah.]

So I have these two trades for my black advent which I'm really unsure with.
I know the ur bw is really high on the main list but would it be easier to trade him off instead of the toxic+hyena? :c
My goal would be something around the ur zonkey.
thank you all for your help!

TRADE O1
TRADE O2

[myth;]

So I have these two trades for my black advent which I'm really unsure with.
I know the ur bw is really high on the main list but would it be easier to trade him off instead of the toxic+hyena? :c
My goal would be something around the ur zonkey.
thank you all for your help!

TRADE O1
TRADE O2

It's a tricky one, the UR Butterfly wolf is a pet that people will either trade fairly for or will not. Even though it doesn't have the best demand, I still think it's better than the toxic and hyena since they are no where near the value of the UR Zonkey (which is currently at 2 nons).

Given that it is a TD BA, you might be able to find someone who will trade their zonkey for it, you may have to add a non or more to your side, but that's the best way to approach it, the BA is popular enough.

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=72731379&userid=548495&signature=bjFrMXyWcvcI-O_vupwzZA

Is this fair, also including demand?

[codyfern]

Trade offer I made

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73141991&userid=776697&signature=40mrA3EVbm8xR6idqkEpjQ

Fair to them or should I edit?

Thank you in advance for any help.

Wrong link

[myth;]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72731379&userid=548495&signature=bjFrMXyWcvcI-O_vupwzZA

Is this fair, also including demand?

Cake dogs are worth about 38-50 2009 rares, the 3 tier 7 advents are worth 18-21 2009 rares between them, which makes it very unfair to the cake dog. I'm unsure of the cake dogs demand, but tier 7s are quite popular.

Trade offer I made

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73141991&userid=776697&signature=40mrA3EVbm8xR6idqkEpjQ

Fair to them or should I edit?

Thank you in advance for any help.

Wrong link

The link works for me?

Their side is worth about 185-195 I do believe, it's near enough fair.
2009 rares = 40-45C$
2009 uncommon = 20C$
2010 rare = 20C$
2015 store pet = 30C$
2014 store pet = 35C$

But because the dragon cat, zodiac, malk dragons, and sitting cat have good demand, they may be worth more.

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72731379&userid=548495&signature=bjFrMXyWcvcI-O_vupwzZA

Is this fair, also including demand?

Cake dogs are worth about 38-50 2009 rares, the 3 tier 7 advents are worth 18-21 2009 rares between them, which makes it very unfair to the cake dog. I'm unsure of the cake dogs demand, but tier 7s are quite popular.

Thank you!
Second opinion (mainly demand)? :3

[shadowphoenixfox]

I'm terrible at understanding the value of items. Is this a fair trade?