The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Animall]

Complete DIY cake set (original) = GWJ?
Would that be fair?
How many balloon dogs would be fair for a GWJ?

It's likely unfair to the DIY cake set. I've only ever seen the set go for around a non. It really depends on where you and your trading partner value it, though, because its only specified to be worth a "high main list pet" - not specifically a non.
The GWJ is worth 2 sorbets + a ur apple, but tends to go for 1-2 sorbs because of demand. 1 sorb = 4 balloon dogs, so it would be worth 4-8 balloon dogs, depending on where you value it.

[Macklin584]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73139924&userid=924297&signature=0aYMYnXMpn48TlB2bF5lWg
What should I add on the person’s side?

[MiniMazarine]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73140613&userid=819108&signature=nhc4MXSFyltY-U-EPLaOIg Fair? (Demand wise too) I'm still so confused of my pets worth AH

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73139924&userid=924297&signature=0aYMYnXMpn48TlB2bF5lWg
What should I add on the person’s side?

Basically the whole worth of the UR Dog. The '09 UR Dog is worth a Green Toxic + Balloon Dog.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73140613&userid=819108&signature=nhc4MXSFyltY-U-EPLaOIg Fair? (Demand wise too) I'm still so confused of my pets worth AH

Very unfair to you. Your dog is worth 12 Mid Advents, their dog is only 1 Mid Advent.

[MiniMazarine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73139924&userid=924297&signature=0aYMYnXMpn48TlB2bF5lWg
What should I add on the person’s side?

Basically the whole worth of the UR Dog. The '09 UR Dog is worth a Green Toxic + Balloon Dog.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73140613&userid=819108&signature=nhc4MXSFyltY-U-EPLaOIg Fair? (Demand wise too) I'm still so confused of my pets worth AH

Very unfair to you. Your dog is worth 12 Mid Advents, their dog is only 1 Mid Advent.

Thank you!

[skyline]

i'm honestly stumped here, i don't want to deal with the bw's demand, but i'm unsure
if i could possibly benefit from it, as i don't know what it's going for, and if it can
get a non that easy. I value my ba at 2 sorbs, so i'm unsure if this'd be better to
take or not, cause i'm not sure what the bw is getting atm, i'd really appreciate
any opinions, thank you!!^^

[Jedi Master Lady Ren]

Is This fair?

[sumatra.]

Thoughts on this trade?
I value my Joker at about 1.5-2 nons, is that what the BEG is also going for?

[popping star]

Is this fair for my C$? (Warning: bulk trade.)

Seeing as the sunjewel goes for 1840, I would say extremely unfair to the C$. I could be wrong though, so get a second opinion.

Thank you! Second opinion?

[dillydallydarlene]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73127562&userid=47800&signature=iOoP6hiD4oiOOEB8X76uJA

Would this be fair? Is the 2008 very rare dog a listie?