The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Ecko]

Which is more fair?

This: trades/viewtrade.php?id=73099915&userid=825391&signature=fwDSZ5tZTv5sQbK2602s3A

Or this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=73092615&userid=825391&signature=h8S7zk8AskhU4u8ZTCzmoQ

Could i get a second opinion?

[darkbay]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73103575&userid=822316&signature=tjQIYsP8bOtz4_vgyF8Eug

Hi! Is this fair?

[inactive...]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73125111&userid=915311&signature=dykafJgHma_eBIUR7guaXg
Hi there! I need a little help with this trade. Do you think that this is fair? Thank you! Even if it is fair, I want to know if you would accept it or not because if I accept it, it also means giving up all my uncommons. Thank you so much! Fair or Unfair? Demand wise?

[Ecko]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73125111&userid=915311&signature=dykafJgHma_eBIUR7guaXg
Hi there! I need a little help with this trade. Do you think that this is fair? Thank you! Even if it is fair, I want to know if you would accept it or not because if I accept it, it also means giving up all my uncommons. Thank you so much! Fair or Unfair? Demand wise?

Very unfair to you. While uncommons do not exactly have a set price, I would personally value the 2018 pets at about 2C$ each. So the trade would only be fair for about 22 of the 2018 pets.

[Trots]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73124304&userid=928891&signature=lWLAOarLwpH7fAS4x1AI6w
Is this fair? Thanks!

[Fat Unicorn]

Which is more fair?

This: trades/viewtrade.php?id=73099915&userid=825391&signature=fwDSZ5tZTv5sQbK2602s3A

Or this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=73092615&userid=825391&signature=h8S7zk8AskhU4u8ZTCzmoQ

Could i get a second opinion?

In terms of overpay, the first trade with the speckled rat has the most overpay. The gap between the speckled and the RBM is roughly around a mid September (and the dark heart being a low main, it definitely bridges the gap and has a surplus of value).

In terms of fairness, the second trade would be more fair for both sides, although it would be slight underpay for the RBM. ^_^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73124304&userid=928891&signature=lWLAOarLwpH7fAS4x1AI6w
Is this fair? Thanks!

Unfair to you, ‘17 store pets are worth roughly a mid ‘10 rare. C:

[Yuroshi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73127694&userid=917768&signature=W6FiNVcfkIbmZn-npakLDg
Is this fair? Thank you for your time

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73127694&userid=917768&signature=W6FiNVcfkIbmZn-npakLDg
Is this fair? Thank you for your time

It's unfair to you. Your dragon is worth a 2010 rare, their side is only worth a little more than a 2016 rare.

[Nira.]

Hello there ^.^
Could anyone tell me how’s this rarity and demand wise?
And whether it’s fair/unfair - if unfair by how much? Or what’s the total worth on UR Cat side?
Thanks in advance ♥

[dragongoddest]

Ok i have a weird thing to ask.
Lets say I auction off my ur butterfly wolf for store pets.
And i value it at two nons
If I values all store pets around an 09 rare how many would i need to be fair?

Edit im not counting the ones on the list already