The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Cacti.]

So should I accept a UR b wolf for my dog tag? With demand I know neither are easy to trade but I’d like to hear just some personal opinions if you just want DM I’m fine with that

[popping star]

So should I accept a UR b wolf for my dog tag? With demand I know neither are easy to trade but I’d like to hear just some personal opinions if you just want DM I’m fine with that

I'd keep the dogtag. The UR bwolf goes for around 2 nons with its demand.
The dogtag goes for fair trades, so it'd be unfair as it's worth 3 nons. (High lists are hard to trade in general as not many have enough to trade for them.)

[Clawdina]

So should I accept a UR b wolf for my dog tag? With demand I know neither are easy to trade but I’d like to hear just some personal opinions if you just want DM I’m fine with that

I'd keep the dogtag. The UR bwolf goes for around 2 nons with its demand.
The dogtag goes for fair trades, so it'd be unfair as it's worth 3 nons.

agreed. Overall, the dogtag will be easier to trade in the long-run

[dear.chaton]

how are these trades in terms of fairness?
x | x | x
Thank you in advance~

I'm not sure about the last one but I know the first and second are unfair to you. A non is worth 1400 cs$ I believe and I know for the first trade that the other pets added to their side does not fox the gap between the non and the GWJ.

A non is worth 1040 C$, not 1400 C$.

thanks, what about this trade?

[nobxdy]

thanks, what about this trade?

It's unfair to the Green Toxic. Your side is worth less than a Line Tribal.

[Clawdina]

thanks, what about this trade?

I'd say unfair to the green toxic strictly rarity wise since your pets only add up to no more than the rainbow mane, so you would need to add about 16 mid-advents which would be about a skeleton pps tier or purple tess horse tier

[spirited away]

really want to know!

[MoonWolf90]

really want to know!

well the sitting cat are just swaps, but idk about the kitsue

[popping star]

really want to know!

well the sitting cat are just swaps, but idk about the kitsue

The warriors are swaps, that is correct.
It's slightly unfair to the kitsune as it's worth an early '09 rare. The elemental cat is a mid '09 rare.
(This is going by rarity. Demand wise, it's up to you and your trading partner.)

[i don't know her]

is this fair? i'm awful at quantity and list, thanks! c: