The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Tara_Markov]

So here are two trades..

This one is still yet to be answered, but I'd appreciate the help

^same one with the items, can I get some help? Thanks!
and this one

I know this is unfair to them rarity wise, but what about demand? I know rats have some horrid demand, so help here would also be great!

Thanks in advance to whoever will answer this !

Any help? Thanks.. (I'd like to know if either of these trades are fair. The first, rarity wise. Second one demand wise)

[Dysautonomia]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72963693&userid=730598&signature=JbJaNFRVnnNHT3RZDCf79w

Is this fair? So unsure bc, well..rat

that'd be about fair
the rat is from August 09. The bunny is a re-release from late 2009. The store pets are together worth an early-mid '09 rare. The b-wolf is worth a '10 uc and fills the gap a little more but it would also be fair without it <3

Perfect! Thank you <33

[myth;]

So here are two trades..

This one is still yet to be answered, but I'd appreciate the help

^same one with the items, can I get some help? Thanks!
and this one

I know this is unfair to them rarity wise, but what about demand? I know rats have some horrid demand, so help here would also be great!

Thanks in advance to whoever will answer this !

Any help? Thanks.. (I'd like to know if either of these trades are fair. The first, rarity wise. Second one demand wise)

I've no idea about the first one, I know the wigs are from the store however. I recommend asking the item worth thread about this one.

Their rat is a flower/toxic rat, it's a tier 6 September list, worth 33 - 40 rares. I've no idea what it's demand is like.
Your side is equal to 16-17 2009 rares (Santa hat dog = 6-7 2009 rares), so you're far under.

[2hollis]

Important: Im not sure if this is worth it but

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jcURqytUEA

[PrettyFinnicky]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72963338&userid=715567&signature=3kmpbThA1pMTdf4jHFQFOQ

This?

[myth;]

Important: Im not sure if this is worth it but

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jcURqytUEA

Unfair to them, a 2012 rare is worth something like 5C$.

[CherriKat]

Important: Im not sure if this is worth it but

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jcURqytUEA

Unfair to them, a 2012 rare is worth something like 5C$.

don't be ridiculous and give fake advice. it is fair to you. a 2011 rare goes for 11-16 c$. you could maybe even ask for a little more.

[.:Cleverfox:.]

Is this fair? I really like the fox but I think the dog has high demand? Also any idea what the scarves go for?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jzkMFDKz3Q

[orion ;;]

is this fair? i'm super rusty on trade stuff ;;

[the]

is this fair? i'm super rusty on trade stuff ;;

Your side is worth little less than rare '12, so they're overpaying

Second Options/Fair?

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3UbErii1zQ

2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lJB2bEhGmg

3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l5UuLSYzlg

4. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FPFAiWrRww

5. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NDnmqpnJtA

6. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sfhi67fBtQ

1. The lime ice rat is worth roughly a 6 mid advents and the angel advent is worth 7, so valuing the may lioness at mid advent it is fair. I wouldn't take it though, as the rat often goes for underpay.

2. They both are on the same tier, so it's a fair swap. Just depends which you prefer.

3. A '16 store pet is worth an early rare '09, while a '14 store pet is worth a mid rare '09, so they're overpaying.

4. Their side isn't even enough for a low advent, so very unfair to you.

5. The UR purple horse is worth 15 mid advents, while your side is adds up to 14, so they're overpaying rarity wise. The horse may be hard to trade off and goes for underpay, so I'd keep the pets personally.

6. Your pets are worth 785-805C$, so unfair to you.