The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Tara_Markov]

So here are two trades..

This one is still yet to be answered, but I'd appreciate the help

^same one with the items, can I get some help? Thanks!
and this one

I know this is unfair to them rarity wise, but what about demand? I know rats have some horrid demand, so help here would also be great!

Thanks in advance to whoever will answer this !

I kinda wanna know??? Help???

[Knovva]

is the lime ice rat worth any omgsr?

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72962989&userid=781327&signature=Yv0dCVRIL0BbeWSFVT9nYQ

Could I get a quick opinion on this? Thank you so much if you can help me ^^

unfair to you. A rare is usually valued at four uncommons from the same year, so their side is only worth 3 '09 rares.

[Trio Cat]

is the lime ice rat worth any omgsr?

no

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

This fair?
dancing.cinnamon~

I'm not the best with item trades so I advise you to get a second opinion but I believe most of those items are store items or not that old (not worth that much) yet so you can easily get them.
They're asking for your September List, and while I know I'm not good with item trades, I'd say this is pretty, if not a lot, unfair to you.

I wouldn't accept it if I were you, but like i said, get a second opinion!^^

Second opinion? If no, what do they have to add item wise? Thank you for any help! Edit: This?? I really need to know for atlessed the top 1

Help please!!

[Mima]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bbNsxOvx0g

I know these recent pets are very high demand, but... '09 rares???

[SpiritKitty]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72963017&userid=819472&signature=5f3ihkCH4jn1bbNsxOvx0g

I know these recent pets are very high demand, but... '09 rares???

personally, I would accept it. I haven't seen really many of the birthday pets (excluding the malk dragon) go for '09 rares. but it's entirely up to how you value your pets.

[Jaax]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72963017&userid=819472&signature=5f3ihkCH4jn1bbNsxOvx0g

I know these recent pets are very high demand, but... '09 rares???

for malk bd pets I usually get 2010 - 09 rares offered so yeah its a bit crazy. I think they a losing a bit of demand though so its all up to you to accept; they are obviously overpaying!

[Dysautonomia]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... T3RZDCf79w

Is this fair? So unsure bc, well..rat

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72963693&userid=730598&signature=JbJaNFRVnnNHT3RZDCf79w

Is this fair? So unsure bc, well..rat :)

that'd be about fair :)
the rat is from August 09. The bunny is a re-release from late 2009. The store pets are together worth an early-mid '09 rare. The b-wolf is worth a '10 uc and fills the gap a little more but it would also be fair without it <3