The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[moth ♡]

xxxxxany ideas on either of these trades?
xxxxxxa
xxxxxxb

[myth;]

URGENT!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fY_MQDHKxQ


oof im really bad at list trades, I need help if this is fair.
If not who is doing over?!!?!??!

Hmmm..
BEG = 1 non
CEG = 1 non
UR Phoenix + 2 Sorbets = 2 nons
Growing white july = 2 sorbets
UR Bengal + Balloon Dog = 1 sorbet
UR Flower Pot = 2 sorbets

So overall, their side is worth over 5 nons, so it's unfair to them.

[Tara_Markov]

So here are two trades..

This one is still yet to be answered, but I'd appreciate the help

^same one with the items, can I get some help? Thanks!
and this one

I know this is unfair to them rarity wise, but what about demand? I know rats have some horrid demand, so help here would also be great!

Thanks in advance to whoever will answer this !

[Lennamoo]

URGENT!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fY_MQDHKxQ


oof im really bad at list trades, I need help if this is fair.
If not who is doing over?!!?!??!

Hmmm..
BEG = 1 non
CEG = 1 non
UR Phoenix + 2 Sorbets = 2 nons
Growing white july = 2 sorbets
UR Bengal + Balloon Dog = 1 sorbet
UR Flower Pot = 2 sorbets

So overall, their side is worth over 5 nons, so it's unfair to them.

Thank you, ill keep that in mind. Good thing I sent it as a suggestion so they could edit it to their liking.

[LionKingdom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cJZI88tF8g

They edited. Is this fair for my warrior cat?

[Trio Cat]

URGENT!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fY_MQDHKxQ


oof im really bad at list trades, I need help if this is fair.
If not who is doing over?!!?!??!

Very Unfair To Your Sunjewel It's On The Main List Plus It's Placed On The Very Top (And Worth Alot). The Pets On The Other Side Is a Trade Down Alot Also It's Overpay.

please dont give false advice or advice if you dont know the rares list well. the other side is overpaying

[Dysautonomia]

Is this fair?
I feel like it's close but I'm not sure.
Thank you

[myth;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72962860&userid=925400&signature=re1bpbVyAAc7cJZI88tF8g

They edited. Is this fair for my warrior cat?

By rarity, it's unfair to them and you'd need to add 1 2009 uncommon and remove all but the 2009 rare from their side.
But demand.. warriors tend to trade for twice their worth, so all they'd need on their side was the 2009 rare.

[moth ♡]

xxxxxany ideas on either of these trades?
xxxxxxa
xxxxxxb

[monochromia]

Is this fair?