The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[HiddenVocals]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72649673&userid=814498&signature=13c-j2WPvdwCtVVs5_Ahcg

I understand it is hard to value a pet with no rarity, but would you guys take this???

I'm really torn on it, so I want to hear other people's opinions!

[kkspecial4]

I believe the sweet potato dog is a 2009?

And I thought the corgi was a store pet?

I believe this is unfair to the top slightly, but am not 100% and would get another opinion, but this is how I got to my conclusion -

Purple Bunny* --> 2 '09 Rares

Corgi = 2013 Store Pet --> 1 Early '09 Rare
Sweet Potato Dog = Halloween 2012

Total Top Worth: 2 '09 Rares + 1 '10 Rare + 1 '16 Rare + 1 '17 Rare - Not including items/commons
Total Bottom Worth: 1 Early '09 Rare + 1 '11 Rare + 1 '10 Rare

*I could not find the bunny on any of the lists and am treating it as a non-list - If I missed it, I apologize

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72633678&userid=916543&signature=i0PyrfUFRUfpsr-SvLImQw

Unfair to the '09 Butterfly Wolf

The top side only adds up to an '09 Uncommon + '10 Uncommon.
The items do not make up the difference as they are from Easter 2016 and Easter 2017.

[Derelyct]

Is this fair for my blue eyed german shepherd?

[MOVED !!!]

WARNING: BULK

Does this look fair? Thanks in advance!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GXLRI9Ofqg

(might be quite unfair to them)(but since they're offering) personally, I would accept,
but it boils down to if you want the pets or not, despite them overpaying a bit ^^;

Also, If I'm correct, older canine PPS have a good 'demand' / are easy to trade off as well.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72649673&userid=814498&signature=13c-j2WPvdwCtVVs5_Ahcg

I understand it is hard to value a pet with no rarity, but would you guys take this???

I'm really torn on it, so I want to hear other people's opinions!

Hmm, all you can get is personal opinions to be honest.
Since these pets aren't the pets usually people* are after right now (malk dragon egg + rarity pups.)
I'd personally accept due to those birthday pets being 'easier' to get than something like the rarity pups.
( this is coming from someone who has 4 hoards of this event aha.. ^ )
And if you ever wanted to get back those birthday pets, going here would be a great option. (swapping thread / if you have any leftover birthday pets.)

[skelliursa]

Would this be a fair trade ? Advent Tier 7 for small bulk of store pets

I know the Advent tier 7s are worth about 7 - 8 '09 Rares, so I think I figured it up correctly ?
But I'm not 100% sure. ;_; Thanks for any help !

Also;
would a Blue Toxic be fair for a Green Liontail ?

[CherriKat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72649673&userid=814498&signature=13c-j2WPvdwCtVVs5_Ahcg

I understand it is hard to value a pet with no rarity, but would you guys take this???

I'm really torn on it, so I want to hear other people's opinions!

REALLY unfair to them. since everyone on chickensmoothie has those pets (they can be adopted by everyone), at most, those pets will be an uncommon. they are overpaying by a lot.

[kkspecial4]

Is this fair for my blue eyed german shepherd?

German Shepherd = 2 '09 Rares within 3 month rule

Since the Black Husky was released during the same month as the Blue Eyed GSD, 2 of them is fair rarity wise.
However, it is up to you if you want to trade the GSD for two of the same pets.

I am unsure on any demand on the VR GSD, but rarity wise it is pretty fair.

[nightmare eyes!]

WARNING: BULK

Does this look fair? Thanks in advance!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GXLRI9Ofqg

(might be quite unfair to them)(but since they're offering) personally, I would accept,
but it boils down to if you want the pets or not, despite them overpaying a bit ^^;

Also, If I'm correct, older canine PPS have a good 'demand' / are easy to trade off as well.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72649673&userid=814498&signature=13c-j2WPvdwCtVVs5_Ahcg

I understand it is hard to value a pet with no rarity, but would you guys take this???

I'm really torn on it, so I want to hear other people's opinions!

Hmm, all you can get is personal opinions to be honest.
Since these pets aren't the pets usually people* are after right now (malk dragon egg + rarity pups.)
I'd personally accept due to those birthday pets being 'easier' to get than something like the rarity pups.
( this is coming from someone who has 4 hoards of this event aha.. ^ )
And if you ever wanted to get back those birthday pets, going here would be a great option. (swapping thread / if you have any leftover birthday pets.)

Thank you!

[MOVED !!!]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72649673&userid=814498&signature=13c-j2WPvdwCtVVs5_Ahcg

I understand it is hard to value a pet with no rarity, but would you guys take this???

I'm really torn on it, so I want to hear other people's opinions!

REALLY unfair to them. since everyone on chickensmoothie has those pets (they can be adopted by everyone), at most, those pets will be an uncommon. they are overpaying by a lot.

I agree. - I have no idea why everyone is overpaying.
The malk dragon eggs, I understand, but everything else? eh.
But still, hope you found my response useful HiddenVocals,
and you're welcome @ halloween smoothie. ^^;

[Dawnstorm111]

any help?