The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[lil rascal]

any help with this item trade is very much appreciated! ;n;
most of those items are older/store ones (83 in total)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XXw6hkHT9w

Since a lot of your items are store items it's basically a C$ trade and just having a quick look at your items it's overpay on your side. The best way to work out how much overpay it is would be to add up the cost of all the items in the store. With the broken up sets divide the total set cost by the amount of items the set is meant to come with & that's your price per piece

[elnachos]

should i accept a gearback tribal for an '09 ur dog? i know the tribal is hard to trade off and normally goes for underpay, but it is a tier above the dog and i'm confused on what to do. thanks!

It's really up to you. I would personally not take it just because I like to do fast trades and the tribal would make me wait too much for replies (which I hate more than anything) since people don't really want them[/quote]

tyvm! second opinion?

[PinkAngel]

was this fair for the pony (it has an id of 250000000) so not sure if if it was fair or not as the ponies id is unique

They overoffered by a lot. Though for IDs I think it depends on what each person values it at. For me IDs don't matter it's the pet. Great job on the catch!

[snowdrake]

would you take this trade?

[Crimson_Raven]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72494436&userid=544717&signature=Vl27GX0a1Y8r6hnhOCnVAA

hi is this fair? thanks

[lil rascal]

(for animal egg 3) opinions? How much does the egg 3 go for??

I've been waiting for an answer for about 3 days now... :c

Probably the reason no one has answered yet is animal egg 3 has no set price so they weren't sure what advice to give. The best way to work out if it is fair or not would be to search animal egg in this thread as there has been discussion over the last few months on the animal eggs 1-4 and many trades shared of what they have gone for so it should give you a general idea of the range it could fetch

[Brianne]

Opinions? It looks like overpay at face value (to me, at least), but what about if demand is taken into consideration? I'm considering accepting because I do like the pet on their side, but I just want to know if it'll be worth it in the long run, as an "investment".

[Lillysong]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -Hq6in4ctw
Is this fair with demand?

[sumatra.]

could anyone give me some insight on how these bids for my BA are?

bid one
bid two
bid three
bid four
bid five
bid six
bid seven

[tissue]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72492050&userid=677783&signature=fQ-WnSsVhfLYGpiEOKoQkg


Fair?