The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mr.scamander]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pMol9jKY6g

Fair?

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this trade worth it? How much do the cake dogs usually go for demand wise? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mKF1MG_y-g

[Ecko]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72120434&userid=847229&signature=GdyJq7wVpLPhpMol9jKY6g

Fair?

A 2016 rare is worth around 2-4C$, so unfair to them.

[dibidibidis]

OH BOYEEEE is this fair i know its quantity but im willing : O

I personally wouldn't -- while store pets have been growing in demand recently, it's still possible to get liontails for 1-1.5 sorbets if you find the right person.
Your side is all high demand -- the Marionette goes for a Sorb easily, as does the Blue Dragon. The BMD historically has gone for Balloon tier, but recently I've seen a bit of a spike in demand, having many people offer Sorbets for my BMD when I had one.
If you value the BMD at a balloon dog, your side would equal approx 2.25 sorbets demand-wise. If you value the BMD at a Sorbet, you'd be offering a Non's worth, in quantity. I've only ever seen the Green Liontail go for that much; I just personally don't feel like it's worth it.
Of course demand is up to you/your trade partner though, so if you really want that Liontail, it's up to you. :D

[rosytea]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72130226&userid=822010&signature=DZ1ciUWP_5hAEeoTi9rrwQ

How about this one??

[WolFox]

I had asked about a trade a bit back. It's been edited since, but the information I was given was:
08 vr = 2 09 rares + 2010 rare
2 2015 store pets = 2 (late) 09 rares
2 2016 store pets = 2 2010 rares
Overpay on your side with one of the 2016 store pets plus the 2013 rare and 2016 rare.

The trade in question was this that I sent with that info.

The tradee got back to me with this, stating the previous offer was "unfair to [them] by one '10 rare or 2016-2018 store pet." I am not interested in the rare cat they have on their side, but with the three store pets on my end from the original offer, is that enough for the '08 wolf?

I would love a few opinions to make sure. Thanks!

[Hauntednightmares]

How Is the demand of the ice rat?

Was this fair? I'm not good with item rarities

~HauntedNightmares

[~Phantom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72130226&userid=822010&signature=DZ1ciUWP_5hAEeoTi9rrwQ

How about this one??

Unfair for you, their pets don't even add up to one '10 rare, whilst you need roughly 3 '10 rares on their side to make it fair, that is without the other pets too.

[Qrawrcorgi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... K4-nBtPK5A

Fair?

[~Phantom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72130648&userid=842708&signature=NvANDZ8FJHv9K4-nBtPK5A

Fair or is not cause we both have our opinions lol

Unfair to them rarity wise, they only need the store pet 2 uncommons from 2010. IF your cat is an actual warrior cat then add another 2 2010 warriors cats. Then should be roughly fair, if and only if yours is a warrior cat, no need for the other pets/items.