The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Silverstar]

zonkey + cinnabun = moonswirl?

the zonkey trades for about 2 nons and the cinnabon for 1.5.
the moonswirl is worth 4 nons, so the zonkey side would need to add a spotted tribal.
some people might value the zonkey and cinnabon at less than that though.

[zach herron.]

please pm your response

[lady gaga]

zonkey + cinnabun = moonswirl?

the zonkey trades for about 2 nons and the cinnabon for 1.5.
the moonswirl is worth 4 nons, so the zonkey side would need to add a spotted tribal.
some people might value the zonkey and cinnabon at less than that though.

okay, thank you so much!!

[thatsokayy]

how is this?

thatsokayy

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this trade worth it? How much do the cake dogs usually go for demand wise? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mKF1MG_y-g

[solarsystem]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72126647&userid=242140&signature=c0huDJ4nREC_q5PmXf0OJg

is this fair? thanks!

[Faybell]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72025736&userid=114864&signature=Gi0MbIrHtnkFLIpv2lz1bg

This is unfair to them right? If I take off the dragon what should I add to my side to make it fair? A very common from the same year?

as it's just two months over the three months rule and thereby a little unfair to them, something like an '11 common/uncommon would be fine.
anyway, the trade would still be considered to be about fair.

Ok gotcha, thanks for helping me sort it out.

[basicallyimbaby]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... n13oJC0VZg

do you think i'll get a better bid than this?

and is this the same value or is it worth more because of demand?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SlJMVCP3Mg

[Saturn ♥]

Is this fair?

Please help?

[WolFox]

I had asked about a trade a bit back. It's been edited since, but the information I was given was:
08 vr = 2 09 rares + 2010 rare
2 2015 store pets = 2 (late) 09 rares
2 2016 store pets = 2 2010 rares
Overpay on your side with one of the 2016 store pets plus the 2013 rare and 2016 rare.

The trade in question was this that I sent with that info.

The tradee got back to me with this, stating the previous offer was "unfair to [them] by one '10 rare or 2016-2018 store pet." I am not interested in the rare cat they have on their side, but with the three store pets on my end from the original offer, is that enough for the '08 wolf?

I would love a few opinions to make sure. Thanks!