The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LostInTheEcho]

Is this a fair trade? Thank you
And is this one and this trade fair?

Unfortunately I can only help with the second trade here. ;w;

The Blue Scarf dog is a 1st tier advent worth 3-4 mixed 09 rares and the rat on your side is worth a mid 09 rare or 2 mid 2010 rares.
Top side is offering about 5 09 rares and a 2010 rare depending on how you value uncommons to rares. I"m using 4-5 uc = 1 rare from that year.

So on that note the top is overpaying by about a 2010 rare.

Thank you so much!
I still need opinions on these two trades 1 and 2. Is any of them fair? Thank you

[literal trash.]

Is this fair to my partner, and if not what would either of add have to add/subtract to make it fair? Thanks in advance. :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mwWTsO7B0g

[Black Clover]

please help with this

[Ecko]

How many 2014 rares can a 2010 comoon dog go for?

Valuing 2 commons to an uncommon and 4 uncommons to a rare. Then a 2010 common is 16 2014 commons which is 8 2014 uncommons and 2 2014 rares.

[sumatra.]

Blue Rose=BMD?

not sure where the demand for the BMDs are right now

[Viozel]

Blue Rose=BMD?

not sure where the demand for the BMDs are right now

I believe they're going for around a balloon dog, though I've heard that some trudates are going for sorbets

[General Chaos]

Is this fair?

[literal trash.]

Is this fair to my partner, and if not what would either of add have to add/subtract to make it fair? Thanks in advance. :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mwWTsO7B0g

[sumatra.]

Blue Rose=BMD?

not sure where the demand for the BMDs are right now

I believe they're going for around a balloon dog, though I've heard that some trudates are going for sorbets

Thank ya, can I get one more opinion?

[Kittyness]

Is this fair for my UR malk?


Let me know what should be added to either side, thank you!!!