The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71220690&userid=919083&signature=uKjXQBCyHvRAN_C7-yOZdw

Is this fair?

Unfair to you, their side is worth a patchy pink September tier
They need to add a scarf pps or 3 mid advents

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71222701&userid=883000&signature=Gj0UxmzNe41uAvw3Pg6B3A
Fair? Please help ^^

Unfair to the sorb. The gap between the two mainlists is a balloon dog, they are only offering a high advents worth

[Derelyct]

A nonballoon for a white 09 christmas deco set, is this fair?
Thank you in advance to any help!

Anyone at all? ;w;

[ilya]

A nonballoon for a white 09 christmas deco set, is this fair?
Thank you in advance to any help!

Anyone at all? ;w;

I believe it is unfair to you, according to this item guide, one garland/light would be worth a sept/main list each, and the ornaments one advent each. I'm not sure about the pants.

[~Loki~]

Hello! Is this trade fair? I’m not sure what quantity advents goes for, or if this is a good offer.

[s a g e]

I believe it is unfair to you, according to this item guide, one garland/light would be worth a sept/main list each, and the ornaments one advent each. I'm not sure about the pants.

agree.
the pants are super hard to find and I think that they could also fetch a main list ^^

[Derelyct]

A nonballoon for a white 09 christmas deco set, is this fair?
Thank you in advance to any help!

I believe it is unfair to you, according to this item guide, one garland/light would be worth a sept/main list each, and the ornaments one advent each. I'm not sure about the pants.

Thank you very much!
I would like a second opinion if possible is anyone else can help.

Edit:

I believe it is unfair to you, according to this item guide, one garland/light would be worth a sept/main list each, and the ornaments one advent each. I'm not sure about the pants.

agree.
the pants are super hard to find and I think that they could also fetch a main list ^^

Thank you! That helps a lot!

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

Is this fair?
I'm not sure about the worth of the items ^^

[sumatra.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cllw-ayBBQ

Is this fair for the zodiac?

[Onyxeva]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71214138&userid=919083&signature=UmmJ17-UZ2Jlcllw-ayBBQ

Is this fair for the zodiac?

Rarity-wise it's unfair to the top since their horse is from late 2009 and the Zodiac dogs go by the 3 month rule.
However the Zodiac dogs have been known to go for an 09 rare/very rare. Which would make the trade fair.

It's up to you on how you value it. :3

[LostInTheEcho]

Is this a fair trade? Thank you
And is this one and this trade fair?

Unfortunately I can only help with the second trade here. ;w;

The Blue Scarf dog is a 1st tier advent worth 3-4 mixed 09 rares and the rat on your side is worth a mid 09 rare or 2 mid 2010 rares.
Top side is offering about 5 09 rares and a 2010 rare depending on how you value uncommons to rares. I"m using 4-5 uc = 1 rare from that year.

So on that note the top is overpaying by about a 2010 rare.

Thank you so much!
I still need opinions on these two trades 1 and 2. Is any of them fair? Thank you