The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Sapphiria]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ip7x8nZpaA

Is this a fair trade demand wise? Thanks!

[Mykie]

I got these two in an auction of mine, which one is better?
- Trade 1
- Trade 2

I also got this trade, and im not sure if its fair ~
Trade 3

[Radioactive Wolf]

Hello, I asked about a similar trade earlier and me and my trading partner agreed on this as the final trade, how fair was it? Sorry to be asking about such a high quantity trade, I know they're a pain!
Thank you so much for any help <3

[kkspecial4]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71065468&userid=693296&signature=QKjqkVXOierjnM8i9_0uug

Is this good? I honestly know nothing aaa

The grey border collie is worth 7-8 09 rares or 85 C$.
The store pets on their side are worth a 10' rare each.
The warrior cats are rereleases from 09 and worth 2 09' rares each.
So one of the warrior cats makes up for the two 09 rare dogs on your side. Then that's an additional three 09 rares, (counting the pony), the store pets, plus 50 C$ for the border collie and 2016 PPS. It depends on how you value your C$, but I think it is about fair. Get a second opinion though.

I agree with the above in that 1 VR Sitting Cat is worth the bottom side's 2 '09 Rares
Converting everything to C$ results in the following:

2017 Store Pets = 20-25 C$ each
Pony = Late '09 Rare = 30-35 C$
Valentine's '09 Sitting Cat = '09 Very Rare = 40-45 C$
April Fools Sitting Cat = '09 Very Rare = 40-45 C$
59 C$
*not including the item in this calculation*

Total C$ = 209-234 C$

Grey Border Collie = Tier 7 Advent = 85 C$
2016 Rare = 2-4 C$
Rainbow Zebra Dog = Early '09 Rare = 40-45 C$
2nd Gen Dog = Late '09 Rare = 30-35 C$

Total C$ = 157-169 C$

Based on the above math this is overpay on the top side, however it depends on how you value the C$ versus the pets.
If you would prefer to have the Tier 7's worth in pets than this is unfair as a Tier 7 Advent is worth 7-8 '09 Rares and the other side is not worth that, but C$ wise the math is above..

*If my math is right. cx

[Bastiodon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71065199&userid=839319&signature=Nn14IVMzxOQ3RpKs7qoDDg can I get some help on this? ((431 items))

[windsorblue17]

I got these two in an auction of mine, which one is better?
- Trade 1
- Trade 2

I also got this trade, and im not sure if its fair ~
Trade 3

The difference between the two isn't humongous.
The first is a tier 7 advent worth 7-8 09 rares. However, it has better demand than the tier five, and easier to trade.
The second is a tier 5 worth 6-7 09 rares and 3 09 rares (valuing the zodiac at an 09 rare), making a total of 9-10 09 rares. However, this advent would be harder to trade.
If you're looking at pure value the second trade would be better!

The third trade is unfair. Your bun is worth 6-7 Mixed 09 Rares + an 09 Uncommon.

[deedee.]

Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Yei9puGLyg

[fιяєfℓу]

Fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CYk8124ENA

[Bastiodon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RpKs7qoDDg can I get some help on this? ((431 items))

[Demonking Urizen]

Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Yei9puGLyg

Unfair to you, a mid 2016 rare is worth a mid 2014 uncommon, two 2015 uncommons would be enough.