The “Is this a fair trade?” thread

[TzatzikiTheLeg]

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

Unfair to you,each of these plushies is worth a '09 rare.Therefore your side=4 '09 rares.
their side doesn't add up to that,they'd need to add 1 '09 rare.
(correct me if I am wrong please people!)

[s a g e]

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

Unfair to you,each of these plushies is worth a '09 rare.Therefore your side=4 '09 rares.
their side doesn't add up to that,they'd need to add 1 '09 rare.
(correct me if I am wrong please people!)

thank you ^^
But for what is 1 plushie going for ?
Because as far as I know, 1 plushie went for multiple 09 rares ?

[TzatzikiTheLeg]

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

Unfair to you,each of these plushies is worth a '09 rare.Therefore your side=4 '09 rares.
their side doesn't add up to that,they'd need to add 1 '09 rare.
(correct me if I am wrong please people!)

thank you ^^
But for what is 1 plushie going for ?
Because as far as I know, 1 plushie went for multiple 09 rares ?

Demand is user based,and these plushies can indeed go for more than 1 '09 rare.However,my opinion is based on how I personally value them,which is why you should get another opinon!

[dogtreat]

If I offer a liontail, clockwork bun & a sorbet is that fair for a raven?

In a another trade I offered that and 40c$. Is that fair or overpay?

ravens/ravendogs are currently fetching a non w/ demand.
a non = 3 sorbets worth.
you offered 2-3 sorbets worth w/ both trades.
but it depends on how ur trading partner values the liontails + clockwork
they will SOMETIMES fetch a sorbets worth each, but not always

hope this helps !!

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

your plushies are worth 1-2 early 2009 rares. and have Very good demand among item collectors
their side is worth i'd say around 2-3 '09 rares at this point. and not all of them early 2009 rares.
i'd say hold on to ur plushies and wait for better offers to come along.

[s a g e]

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

your plushies are worth 1-2 early 2009 rares. and have Very good demand among item collectors
their side is worth i'd say around 2-3 '09 rares at this point. and not all of them early 2009 rares.
i'd say hold on to ur plushies and wait for better offers to come along.

Thank you for your opinion c:

And what do you think about this ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rOTo62hTEA

[Sweet flower!]

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

your plushies are worth 1-2 early 2009 rares. and have Very good demand among item collectors
their side is worth i'd say around 2-3 '09 rares at this point. and not all of them early 2009 rares.
i'd say hold on to ur plushies and wait for better offers to come along.

Thank you for your opinion c:

And what do you think about this ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rOTo62hTEA

I think that is fair cause of the lists

[dogtreat]

is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zl93Fhv2IQ

please consider the demand of these plushies ^^

your plushies are worth 1-2 early 2009 rares. and have Very good demand among item collectors
their side is worth i'd say around 2-3 '09 rares at this point. and not all of them early 2009 rares.
i'd say hold on to ur plushies and wait for better offers to come along.

Thank you for your opinion c:

And what do you think about this ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rOTo62hTEA

this is fair rarity and demand wise afaik.
their side is worth 9-10 '09 rares.
but it demands how you personally value your items/if ur a collector imo.

[moonfingers]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TyKPLyWTHQ

[hayzel]

rarity and demand wise, could i have some help with this? thank you in advance c:

[pigeon -]

would this be fair?

Rarity wise,no,because the UR Cucumber is worth 2 non-dogs + yellow/green toxic.Demand wise,I believe it goes for about a non,so fair-ish,valuing the beg at a non due to demand.It's up to you whether you are willing to pay more than a non's worth for the UR Cucmber(again,valuing the beg at a non).

with demand the pickle is unfortunately only worth about 1-2 nons. (1.5 is standard)
the BEG/black eyed galaxy can sometimes fetch a non w/ demand but its more likely to fetch 2 sorbs.
so it's not really a very fair trade for the pickle tbh.
especially because the roses are mid-september and a balloon dog and don't begin to make up the extra worth imo.

Thank you! Could i get some more opinions on demand wise? Would it be worth trading up to trade back down again?