The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Meridiem]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70589235&userid=875611&signature=9Nk9jmqGxDN2xFz-3JYQNg

Urgent!
Is this fair? Thanks a lot!

Even with the rats' terrible demand, your side doesn't amount to even one of the VR rats so its extremely unfair to the rat side

[Meridiem]

I'm terrible at '09 trading! please help! thank you in advance <3

Unfair to the 09, their uncommon pets don't make up another 2010 rare.

Thank you! second opinion?

I agree, the uncommons dont add the spoace between the 09 and 10 rare

[avanhellica]

How is this? X

I believe that's unfair to you. A 2015 store pet is worth roughly an early '10 rare.
Your dog is a rerelease of an '08 dog from november if I'm not mistaken c:

[agust]

How is this? X

I believe that's unfair to you. A 2015 store pet is worth roughly an early '10 rare.
Your dog is a rerelease of an '08 dog from november if I'm not mistaken c:

I agree! Very unfair to your card dog.

[Meridiem]

How is this? X

I believe that's unfair to you. A 2015 store pet is worth roughly an early '10 rare.
Your dog is a rerelease of an '08 dog from november if I'm not mistaken c:

I agree! Very unfair to your card dog.

Thank you to both of you

[Alstroemeria]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1mRB-i30zQ

[ericarawrr]

Is this fair? If not what needs to be added?

and in case that one doesn't work out, how are these?

Trade 1
Trade 2

[Sharpwater]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Go2GakjHNg is this fair? ive been offered it twice and i have no idea

[agust]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1mRB-i30zQ

Yes, it's fair, if not a little over on the betta fish side. 2018 store pets are worth late 2010 rares.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70589019&userid=849144&signature=BYZ7WAjx7wYrGo2GakjHNg is this fair? ive been offered it twice and i have no idea

From what I've seen, your little Zonkey goes for two nons. They are only offering one.

[Keen]

Is this fair?

They're undertrading, as recent store pets usually go for 1-2 09' rares. Even with the other pets and items, it's still unfair. Items in my opinion are also harder to trade off.

I disagree. The store pets only go for a 2010 rare each.

Okay so... What is the consensus here? I didn't really understand this convo XD