The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LovelyRita]

im holding an auction and I was wondering would this bid be a big overpay for this group (it contains one of every lion on the site, please take demand into account)

[Maeja]

click

opinions?
i mostly want quantity for her

[hyukoh]

fair demand wise?
thank you!

EDIT is this fair demand wise? i value the raven at 1.5 nons and i want quanity for him so im not sure??
thank you so much for any help!!

[Pinkiyoshi64]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LO_IgqlpGA
Is this fair? The other vr is 2009 as well.

[the]

Is this fair?
The sender said this with the trade (don't know if the message is visible to everyone or just me): "2014 store pet roughly equals to a 2010 rare. The 2009 UC should cover that fact"

No, they're lying. A '14 store pet is worth a mid '09 rare or 4 mid '09 uncommons, not one.

[Pinkiyoshi64]

Is this fair?
The sender said this with the trade (don't know if the message is visible to everyone or just me): "2014 store pet roughly equals to a 2010 rare. The 2009 UC should cover that fact"

I don’t know much about trading but I’m pretty sure that a 2009 uncommon doesn’t equal a 2010 rare, likes maybe two or three would but I don’t think just one does. Also store pets gain rarity more due to not rereleasing. But get a second opinion ^_^

[miteinander]

Opinions? I'm really not sure if I'm underpaying or not.
((If I need to add or reduce, how much and what?))

I think that is pretty fair rarity wise,

Thank you. May I have a second take?

[Chocolatesoup123]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70432880&userid=843446&signature=k3N4zIGBq4iuezsSgFeaOA

Is this fair? I know that rats have less demand and I generally don't like them as much either. (Could anyone also please tell me what my pet is worth?)

Thanks!

Your horse is worth the 3 month rule or 2 '09 rares
A '08 rare is worth a '09 rare and a '09 uncommon, so the top is worth a '09 rare plus a '10 rare. This trade is unfair to you

Thank you!

[hyukoh]

fair demand wise?
thank you!

EDIT is this fair demand wise? i value the raven at 1.5 nons and i want quanity for him so im not sure??
thank you so much for any help!!

[LovelyRita]

im holding an auction and I was wondering would this bid be a big overpay for this group (it contains one of every lion on the site, please take demand into account)