The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wolf Storm]

Is this fair?

[LovelyRita]

Is a purple toxic fair for my punk dog set?

[emjayy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70378885&userid=26641&signature=PDb71vGefLEa-oeF6kvelQ

i dunno how I feel about it, yeah what they're offering is super rare BUT I think there is more demand for my pets. What do you guys think?

I personally wouldn't accept this. Rarity wise it's unfair to the July PPS but they are very hard to trade of fairly. Even valuing it at 1.5 nons the dogtag, sorb and marionette (valuing at a sorb) alone would be over. I think you're better off with your well-sought after quantity ^^

[Dizzy socks]

I would really appreciate any advice - thank you!

[agust]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70378885&userid=26641&signature=PDb71vGefLEa-oeF6kvelQ

i dunno how I feel about it, yeah what they're offering is super rare BUT I think there is more demand for my pets. What do you guys think?

I personally wouldn't accept this. Rarity wise it's unfair to the July PPS but they are very hard to trade of fairly. Even valuing it at 1.5 nons the dogtag, sorb and marionette (valuing at a sorb) alone would be over. I think you're better off with your well-sought after quantity ^^

I agree, the July PPS can be very hard to trade off, and quantity like this always has great demand. If you're looking to climb the list, it's a good offer. But if you prefer all of the pets you have now, there is no pressure to take it

[miilk]

Hello y’all, I have a pretty serious (to me anyways lol) trade. I don’t care that rats have bad demand, I see them as equals to dogs. So don’t include that please. I just need to know if it is fair or not c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gl49WR7POA

It’s urgent, so please help me (:

[Audrey_Bee]

Hey! i was just wondering what your thoughts are on this trade?? am i asking for too much? i don't mind overpaying slightly due to the huge amount of pets on their side? (: thank you for any help given!!

so this was a lot of math to do so i could be wrong and made a misstep so i would get a second opinion but i think i mostly did everything right? we'll see i guess. anyway, i counted a tier 1 advent, shima (goes for low advent), 6 tier 5 advents, 1 tier 9 advent, nonjewel, pps cat (goes for low advent), tier 4 september list (7 mid-advents), 2 tier 7 advents, ceg, and 1 tier 3 advent for list pets. that's two nons (ceg fetches nons with demand) and about 130 '09 rares with all the advents and the september. then there are about 124-130 miscellaneous 2009 rares (valuing 2009 very rares as 2 2009 rares, uncommon warriors as a 2009 rare, zodiacs as 4 rares each, 2008 rare as 3 2009 rares, store pets as 1-3 depending on age and demand) sunjewels are worth 5 nons, and there are 2 nons and 260 2009 rares here. in other words, you are asking for way too little in my opinion. one non is worth roughly 1500-2000 2009 rares, so basically you're just asking for two nons and then maybe a half of a sorbet for a 5 non-worth pet?

again, get a second opinion, but even if you're willing to overpay, if my math is correct, you're still like way overpaying.

Thank you so so much !!! I really appreciate the response,I know how difficult it is to add it all up♡♡ thank you!

I knew it was quite a big overpay I'm my side but it's super hard to get a trade down. I've offered for 4 nons worth of pets and people seem repulsed by the idea I'm at a bit of a cross road with this one:(

[LovelyRita]

Is a purple toxic fair for my punk dog set?

[Wolf Storm]

Is this fair?

[kkspecial4]

Hello y’all, I have a pretty serious (to me anyways lol) trade. I don’t care that rats have bad demand, I see them as equals to dogs. So don’t include that please. I just need to know if it is fair or not c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gl49WR7POA

Rat is a Late 2009 Very Rare.
2014 Store Pet is worth a Late 2009 Rare.
I am going to ignore the 2010 Uncommon for now because it does not really help make up the difference.
The 20 C$ is equivalent to a current store pet so a Late 2010 Rare.

1 2009 VR = 2 2009 Rares would be a fair swap valuing both evenly.

But the total from the trade looks like this instead:
1 2009 VR = 1 2009 Rare + 1 2010 Rare

Store Pet side is underpaying (not taking into account any demand the store dog may have).

I would get another opinion