The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shadow2204]

Hello there!
Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DEEsUwSgAw
thanks in advance! ^^

Edit:
This one too?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a8M5jeEI7g
Thanks again! ^^

Edit:
This one as well?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1F5JadPk2A
They're saying my side would be for one of their very rares + one rare, or three rares. Not sure if that adds up?
Thanks ^^

1. Unfair. 80C$ is worth a hyena bun tier & the uncommon doesn't make up for it (the dog is worth 85C$), and usually it's not recommended to trade lists for C$ unless you're looking for C$.
2. They are overpaying by a '09 rare by rarity.
3. Definitely super unfair. You have 3 list pets on your side... Their side is worth 18 '09 rares. That pink striped september dog alone is worth 24-32 '09 rares.

[bleak.]

Is this fair?

[Tigerice7]

Hello there!
Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DEEsUwSgAw
thanks in advance! ^^

Edit:
This one too?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a8M5jeEI7g
Thanks again! ^^

Edit:
This one as well?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1F5JadPk2A
They're saying my side would be for one of their very rares + one rare, or three rares. Not sure if that adds up?
Thanks ^^

1. Unfair. 80C$ is worth a hyena bun tier & the uncommon doesn't make up for it (the dog is worth 85C$), and usually it's not recommended to trade lists for C$ unless you're looking for C$.
2. They are overpaying by a '09 rare by rarity.
3. Definitely super unfair. You have 3 list pets on your side... Their side is worth 18 '09 rares. That pink striped september dog alone is worth 24-32 '09 rares.

Thanks so much! ^^ Have a great day!

[Shadow2204]

Is this fair?

Unfair. Line tribal + balloon dog = between a green toxic & red toxic.
Also, jokers goes for a non with demand.

[xnocturnalkittenx]

Hi there! Never really got any feedback on this one http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oCkYf7fwfQ
Would like to know what to do to make it fair if it's not already. Thank you!

[Catula]

Is this fair rarity + demand wise? Thanks in advance!

[nobxdy]

Just ignore this lol.

[Shadow2204]

Hi there! Never really got any feedback on this one http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oCkYf7fwfQ
Would like to know what to do to make it fair if it's not already. Thank you!

Their side is worth around a little more than 2 '09 rares + '10 rare + 1 '13 rare.
Your side is worth a 4 '09 rares + a '11 rare.

They would need to add 1 '09 rare + a '10 rare + 3 '13 rares to be fair.

Is this fair rarity + demand wise? Thanks in advance!

Unfair rarity wise so it would be even more unfair with demand.
100C$ = Sockdog. Their side is worth a green toxic tier which is 1/6 of the non's worth.

[AuroraButterflyx]

Fair. Idk what the their item worth.http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... k9enb9D3AA

[.Animal.]

Are this fair? Which is the best for my Warrior cat?

Warrior cat

Items

1. They're offering the worth of a little more than 5 '09 rares which is overpay.
2. Unsure; i'm not good with items

Thank you! Could i get one more opinion before I decide? And I really need a second opinion on the Item trade, I’ve been asking for over 24 hours now and I don’t want to keep them waiting. Someone said I could get more from my items, but I’d really like another opinion.