The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[marmoris]

x

this? i don’t know anything about items & i’m not too sure about the pets either

Rarity wise this is overpay, but I wouldn’t accept if I were you. The banana has really poor demand, it seems to get a non and that’s all. the flower also has low demand goes for underpay as well. Overall if you don’t care about demand, then it’s great, but you’ll never be able to trade the two pets fairly demand wise.

[Elnyn]

Hi again!

I need some help with this trade:

08 halo
I know the Halo is worth a September list pet, would I be worth keeping the Halo instead of trading them for low demand pets?


quantity for list
Anyone have an idea if this is worth it, too? :)

Thank you!

[angel furby]

x

this? i don’t know anything about items & i’m not too sure about the pets either

Rarity wise this is overpay, but I wouldn’t accept if I were you. The banana has really poor demand, it seems to get a non and that’s all. the flower also has low demand goes for underpay as well. Overall if you don’t care about demand, then it’s great, but you’ll never be able to trade the two pets fairly demand wise.

thank you!!

[~Forgotten Dreams~]

A bulk offer for my Malk Dragon! I really want to work this out, so specific advice is appreciated, as we're both bad at list values. Thanks!

if i'm correct, i see four mid-advents there (butterbun, border collie, blue flower, and kiss pps) and the dragon cat pps can fetch advent lists so you could count that as a fifth. and a malk dragon is worth about 8-9 mid-advents(demand not considered). since a mid-advent is worth 7-8 '09 rares, they would owe you another 24 '09 rares. (they might be there and i am just too lazy to count) this is not taking demand into consideration though so i would try and get a second opinion with demand in mind since i don't bother to keep up with demand spikes. hope this helps!

Thank you this is super helpful! Anyone else know about demand?

[.Animal.]

Could I get more for my pets/items in either of these trades?

X
X
X

[Constellation.]

Hey, would you do this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0FhnTNWX6w

On the other side and would also like to know if we need to negotiate. (:

[theupsidedown]

The starting offer was overpay on their side. The newest trade is overpay on your side. Each 2013 store pet is worth a mid 09 rare. A 08 rare is worth an 09 rare + 2010 rare.

thank you!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dLiOhvLTkw
also, what do these pets add up to? only the store pets though, ignore the lists + items. i know its not worth the zeeb, just wondering what i could trade them instead

[whitney!]

this or this?

[~Forgotten Dreams~]

this or this?

Honestly not sure about the first one, but the second one is really unfair to you

[I Like Bees]

Is this trade fair? I'm asking for a friend, since I want to be sure that she's not scammed. Thank you for any and all help!