The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[zenzi]

Their side is just over 1 non in value, so you're over. The basilisk have very good demand, I was once offered a low main for my set.

okay, what could i remove from my side then?
(plus thanks boodles!)

Hmm.. maybe all the basilisks, because as boodles said they can trade for balloon dogs or more, and maybe all rares but 1 2009 rare for the items?

I'd say it's a fair trade, their side is worth a non + balloon dog. even if you get a red X pps for each of the sets, they'd still be overpaying by a few mid advents.

[Bruhhitskayla]

is this bid fair? id like to know in advance
thank you

Demand wise, its sorta fair. Dates are okay too!

[theupsidedown]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rNOdGNs_Hw please help! what would be needed to bridge the gap?

[Catlover1000]

I'm running an auction but I'm not sure if any of these are actually fair, can somebody help me?http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70338082&userid=889550&signature=2ESisbp4S3Gkz49IpMbItg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z5IFCE4kdA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... W3JemrRdHQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eFO-PUOQIQ
Thank you!

I got some nice answers(thanks!) but would like another opinion, Anyone else?

[myth;]

is this bid fair? id like to know in advance
thank you

Unfair to you, the July PPS is worth 2 nons, so they need to add just under 2 sorbets.
@ Bruhhitskayla - Please don't give false advice like that, the amount of quantity makes no difference to the overall pet values.

[boodles]

is this bid fair? id like to know in advance
thank you

Demand wise, its sorta fair. However, quantity would make this more fair, as your pet is very high demand! Dates are okay too!

Please don’t give false advice. The July PPS is worth 2x what they are offering. It does have bad demand, and therefor goes for less, closer to what they are offering (1 non) but that is up to you if you want to accept that. Being patient could get you more.

[amon.]

is this bid fair? id like to know in advance
thank you

Demand wise, its sorta fair. However, quantity would make this more fair, as your pet is very high demand! Dates are okay too!

Please don’t give false advice. The July PPS is worth 2x what they are offering. It does have bad demand, and therefor goes for less, closer to what they are offering (1 non) but that is up to you if you want to accept that. Being patient could get you more.

i see, thank you

[marmoris]

is this bid fair? id like to know in advance
thank you

Demand wise, its sorta fair. However, quantity would make this more fair, as your pet is very high demand! Dates are okay too!

Don’t give false advice. The July PPS is worrh two nons, and doesn’t have any special demand.
As for the offer, I wouldn’t accept as they are only offering a non and a red-x PPS. The rares DO NOT fill in the gap even remotely. While the PPS doesn’t always go for a full two nons you can usually get at least 1.5 nons.

Quantity does not make a trade fair, as none of the pets thy added except the red-x are list pets.

[myth;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70342253&userid=735027&signature=OPp4bmFH1J-srNOdGNs_Hw please help! what would be needed to bridge the gap?

With the demand of the zebras on the rise (they're worth 3 nons but can trade for 2), they need to add at least 2 nons, they're side doesn't even add up to a low main list.

[Classification]

Fair? Im the side with the sitting cats http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... P2GJjxad3Q