The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[Firefoxx01]

Which would you accept, and why? If you would edit, what would you add?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SZC5eCDBeQ

-or-

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uQKNb-NTZw

Firefoxx01

[tigie9k]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... S7LfQlJ5XA

How does my side look

NEVERMIND THEY CANCELED

[dear.chaton]

How’s this for the sorbet?
Thank you in advance~

[lucky333123]

Which would you accept, and why? If you would edit, what would you add?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SZC5eCDBeQ

-or-

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uQKNb-NTZw

Firefoxx01

The first one is unfair to them due to the VR rats.

The second one is unfair to you. Even though warrior cats have demand, I usually see the rare ones go for more, not normally the uncommon ones.

[malkav,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70207580&userid=825067&signature=KcDNxmlcMY7dAzuvvXnQVw
Is this alright for both sides? Please try to hurry, I do not want to keep then waiting

Please help hhh, sorry if this sounds so pesky^^´

the dog is the white february from '09, and actually has pretty good demand, going for slight overpay most of the time, from what i've noticed. your warrior cat is an extended release from 08, which also has a pretty fair demand. rarity wise, it's a little underpay on the warrior's side due to the difference of dates between the warrior and white february (per the three month rule) but demand wise i really think it's up to which you prefer, as a lot of warriors can usually fetch a bit more than they're worth.

the uncommons are completely fair - they fall within the 3 month rule.

hope this helps!

[lucky333123]

How’s this for the sorbet?
Thank you in advance~

I would say unfair to you. Their side won’t add up to the value of the sorbet.

[boodles]

Purple Toxic for a UR Foal?

I know they are on the same tier but with demand is it a fair swap or should someone add?

[crucifying.]

Purple Toxic for a UR Foal?

I know they are on the same tier but with demand is it a fair swap or should someone add?

the demand on them is equivalent. it's a fair swap.

[dear.chaton]

How’s this for the sorbet?
Thank you in advance~

I would say unfair to you. Their side won’t add up to the value of the sorbet.

Ah thank you! What could they add to make it fair?

[Kitkat2716]

Any help is greatly appreciated!! I know it’s unfair rarity but with the quantity and quality is this a good option or would I be better off with 3 nons?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 002OSBQ2bg