The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[a.common.diplet]

Zonkey for Coontail?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LdH2eQ-I-g

[ʙʀᴏᴋᴇᴅ™]

i feel like this is unfair to them but im not sure.. any thoughts? is this fair?

Extremely unfair to the peach.

ah okay. thanks

[justina valentine]

[quote=Maddy"]

thoughts?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y9ox4BTkcQ
not sure if the items add up

Yeah, a bit unfair to the dog, even if some of the items are valued around an 09 R/VR.

Okay thank you how many items worth one 09 r/vr would need to be added and I also heard confetti isnt worth that much.

Definitely use this guide for determining older item worth (:

The turtle dove is worth about a late? 09 rare (mid 09 rare/VR if they're pairs of turtle doves, since they were released in pairs)
Purple horse, and hearts, are a mid 09 r/vr each.
The socks are a late 09 R/vr.
Unsure about chocolate box and confetti.[/quote]

I have seen that item forum before but ill remember to look at it more often when doing a trade.
So there side counts as about 4 09 rares so how much is the tier 5 worth??

thanks so much for the help Maddy!

[ʙʀᴏᴋᴇᴅ™]

i feel like this is unfair to them but im not sure.. any thoughts? is this fair?

edit: if i add a bmd to the trade will that be unfair to them? or will i still be overpaying? or would it be fair?

[The Plague.]

How about this? <3 Thanks to anyone who answers, it mean a whole lot!

[Maddy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70070949&userid=58226&signature=Twe2QNItCUG3oggPBv5Sog

Is this fair?

Pretty sure it's a bit unfair to the top.

[Maddy]

i feel like this is unfair to them but im not sure.. any thoughts? is this fair?

edit: if i add a bmd to the trade will that be unfair to them? or will i still be overpaying? or would it be fair?

Wait, what? If you add a bmd? To your side? It's already unfair to you (UR peach). If you add a bmd to their side, it's still unfair to you. Peach is mainlist.

[casket]

who would have to add/how much?

[~randomidiot~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zXxuwBFLxQ


Was this fair? (My pet was 23 days old)

Unfair to you I'm afraid. The pet is exactly the same. Overpay is usually given for a true date, not one that's one year younger but still a re-release(: not sure exactly how much that item is worth it anything added to your side with the dog would be been overpay ♡

But I thought my pet wasn't PPS as he was suppose to become PPS at 13 days. But he's still growing. Is that correct?

No, it was unfair to me. I though it was going to be the same but mine is an advent list and yours is a normal 2009 rare. This was my first December 18th and I already messed up, I sent back a trade so please get back to me

[qbaiter]

clicky

help anyone?
I was told previously in the thread that patchworks
have good demand and they've seen them go for
sorbs recently due to store pet demand. not sure
on how accurate this is and I'd like a second(?)
opinion! how is this trade rarity/demand wise?
any help is appreciated in advance!