The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[Legacyy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69709032&userid=870724&signature=6Ng3I13wgCKEPTflU27zjg

demand included?

[salfishmask]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69688368&userid=140650&signature=Gj5WnHXT9sps9KKKB7wD9w

Does this trade seem fair? I'm unsure about what the ur tiger goes for based on demand

Quite fair considering that the sunjewel is technically the same worth as the ur tiger and then you have a growing sunpup added onto it. Might be best you can get demand wise

[Grottan]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69688368&userid=140650&signature=Gj5WnHXT9sps9KKKB7wD9w

Does this trade seem fair? I'm unsure about what the ur tiger goes for based on demand

Depends on the outcome, I suppose. The Non-jewl is most likely of the two, which would make the trade under despite the fact that the SunJewl is matching the TD's tier. The TD goes for overpay as it is massively a very over-loved dreamie. You could get more I think, demand wise-as the only Sun-dog with REALLY good demand seems to be the Sunback. (Which goes for allot, sunjewl++++)

[salfishmask]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69688368&userid=140650&signature=Gj5WnHXT9sps9KKKB7wD9w

Does this trade seem fair? I'm unsure about what the ur tiger goes for based on demand

Depends on the outcome, I suppose. The Non-jewl is most likely of the two, which would make the trade under despite the fact that the SunJewl is matching the TD's tier. The TD goes for overpay as it is massively a very over-loved dreamie. You could get more I think, demand wise-as the only Sun-dog with REALLY good demand seems to be the Sunback.

Agree actually

[tucawt]

Would a trade offering a sorbet for a patchwork dog be fair?
Thanks! <3tucawt

[Bastiodon]

we're both unsure, what would need to be changed(if it's not fair)?

[Legacyy]

Would a trade offering a sorbet for a patchwork dog be fair?
Thanks! <3tucawt

it should be fair, yes ^^

[dustnbones]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69708999&userid=890691&signature=Hd7NcXIHssq_EsLNINBvhA
is this fair? a pink patched september for a red-fronted hollydog?

[minoosh]

What would they have to add?
XXX

[Legacyy]

we're both unsure, what would need to be changed(if it's not fair)?

on the other side, I know its not fair how many '09 rares or mid advents would need to be added