The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[~Cookies And Milk~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ctVeUf5ocg

Can I have another opinion on this is it fair to me plz pm me

[Galaxy Figs]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69595756&userid=655212&signature=VYoj1faqM5JirqUYubg6yw

Not sure if the pps lion can go for more or not.

Unless the PPS lion is worth more (which I don't think it is), a 2017 rare is about worth a 2015 uncommon. So a bit unfair to the rare side.

[justina valentine]

*snip*

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69642966&userid=106411&signature=grWGEHp2j273aNPkrmN69g

This fair? It's one of the only decent offers for my zebra I've gotten. Thanks!

I know this is underpay, but could I realistically get any more then this?[/quote][/quote]


I would personally take this to be honest with you, rarity wise yes this is very unfair to you but demand wise I'd take it, only cause the most I have gotten out of a zebra is a ceg the demand of the aussie is a bit iffy but if you don't want to wait for a better offer I'd take it (i love the aussies design maybe thats also why i'd take it) just demands if you want to wait for a better offer which could take ages or if you just wanna get rid of the zebra (i find zebras go easier when they are in there baby stages i was able to trade my baby zebra which i had ages ago that i traded for someone got it from the monthly adopts well i was able to trade it for a raven.)
So this is basically personal preference but i would get another opinion.

[GhostPants]

How does this look? Any help is appreciated!
@Gasoline

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ctVeUf5ocg

Can I have another opinion on this is it fair to me plz pm me

already gave you an opinion on page 251





here it is (:

Okay so let me do the math.
yellow sorbet + blue toxic + bmd = about a non and red x pps
patchwork + marionette + purple toxic = about a non and small add depending on the person
seal pps + andriod + punk + punk + tess pup = mid September - low mainlist
red + green + yellow + purple toxics = about a non and a half maybe a bit less depending on the player
rainbow mane + purple horse + 3 store horses set + growing july = about a non and a half again depending on the player
trible pup + nick horse + x pps = from a sorbet - a non (if i rememebr straight and ) cause the trible pup is still growig
so there has a chance of the whole trade being worth four nons - 5 and a half nons depending on who you trade cause people have different opinions on the pets
but i wouldnt take this for your tiger you can get up to 10 nons if you are patient
and most of these pets dont have the best demand
get a second opinion hope i could help a bit!
merry christmas! <3

[vein]

Hello!
Is this trade fair?
I believe that is is unfair to the PPS but I very well could be wrong.

[Galaxy Figs]

*snip*

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69642966&userid=106411&signature=grWGEHp2j273aNPkrmN69g

This fair? It's one of the only decent offers for my zebra I've gotten. Thanks!

I know this is underpay, but could I realistically get any more then this?

[/quote]


I would personally take this to be honest with you, rarity wise yes this is very unfair to you but demand wise I'd take it, only cause the most I have gotten out of a zebra is a ceg the demand of the aussie is a bit iffy but if you don't want to wait for a better offer I'd take it (i love the aussies design maybe thats also why i'd take it) just demands if you want to wait for a better offer which could take ages or if you just wanna get rid of the zebra (i find zebras go easier when they are in there baby stages i was able to trade my baby zebra which i had ages ago that i traded for someone got it from the monthly adopts well i was able to trade it for a raven.)
So this is basically personal preference but i would get another opinion.[/quote]
Cool thank you! I'm leaning towards taking it too, but does the UR Aussie have bad demand? I thought it had pretty solid demand, which was a big part of why I wanted to take it (idk if I wanna keep it, there's other stuff close to it on the list I would rather have.

Second opinion?

[justina valentine]

Hello!
Is this trade fair?
I believe that is is unfair to the PPS but I very well could be wrong.

You are correct it is unfair to the pps, the pps is on the main list and can go for far more than this.

[andreá]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... urpE5Yw5Lw

Can I have help with this trade ASAP?

[vein]

Hello!
Is this trade fair?
I believe that is is unfair to the PPS but I very well could be wrong.

You are correct it is unfair to the pps, the pps is on the main list and can go for far more than this.

thank you! <3