The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[StrawberryMarble]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pyWMHDzTFQ

[infinitestarsx]

all of these are bids for the whole zodiac dog set.

trade 1

trade 2

trade 3

trade 4

trade 5

trade 6

trade 7

trade 8

could someone tell me the order of rarity from greatest to least? thank you!

please note that i am looking for c$ so don't tell me that a trade is bad just because it is mainly c$.

[mgs]

trade one & trade two
which one is the most fair demand-wise? thank you in advance <3

[hyena.]

trade one & trade two
which one is the most fair demand-wise? thank you in advance <3

Neither are particularly appealing demand wise. The holly dog usually trades for about its worth often a bit less because it’s a ‘seasonal’ pet. Taking demand into account, the galaxy dogs will usually trade for non tier dogs (a tier above the hollywing)

The ur bw is tricky because a lot of people don’t like it and from my experience I’ve usually traded them for a non or maybe a bit more - in my most recent experience I managed to swap in for a zebra although their demand is nothing noteworthy either.

Neither are spectacular demand wise but number two looks like the better option if I had to pick one (personally, I wouldn’t trade for either or I would trade only the galaxy pup and neither the sorbet nor balloon.)

[Mewfle]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69540615&userid=879667&signature=9dcOJm-i_BHypyWMHDzTFQ

Unfair to you by quite a bit, their side would add up to a low september at most, while your growing pup is a definite mainlist. I would suggest locking it up until it's grown to the pup stage.

[loulouie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0rYDeGg4QA


;oo helpp

[XxMudkip77xX]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69566022&userid=858447&signature=cII5lC9D6oES0rYDeGg4QA


;oo helpp

That looks fair to me. I think the no balloon dog on their side is worth it by itself. Im not too sure so try to get a second opinion

[loulouie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69566022&userid=858447&signature=cII5lC9D6oES0rYDeGg4QA


;oo helpp

That looks fair to me. I think the no balloon dog on their side is worth it by itself. Im not too sure so try to get a second opinion

thank you D second opinions?

[Kuro_]

This?

[hyena.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69540615&userid=879667&signature=9dcOJm-i_BHypyWMHDzTFQ

Massively unfair to you by anything ranging from at least a line tribal to CE galaxy depending on outcome. Their side barely adds up to a bottom tier September.