The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Zelda the Wolf]

i really need some expert advice on this

I wouldn't take it, didn't you get offered a sunjewel for those 4 pets?

The sunback is worth more demand wise then sunjewel xD

[GhostPants]

Im back again =u= how does this trade look? i looked on the 'what is this worth?' thread and it said it was 7-8 09' pets, so would im offering be fair? Tysm in advance!

@Gasoline

[xianlany]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69557983&userid=650789&signature=4rIjKMf5RpSs-gh1MYxcCA

opinions about this?

Very unfair to you, while the demand on the peas is all over the place, they are still worth a main list at least. Their side is an advent list.

Thanks for the input! About how much more should they add? (if someone could tell me the value in rares as well as store pets that would be great!) <-

Edit: I was offered a dark blue toxic for the peas, is that under as well? <-

Edit 2: Another offer for the peas, this time a speckled rat. The same question as in edit 1. <-

arrows are questions that have not been answered yet

[jaysnarnia]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69556236&userid=79238&signature=ZihG30UhWODU8sQ8kc6rLQ

i just want someone's opinion on this one!

[Plumsauce]

blue rose dog + ? = BMD
Please help!

[Heliodor]

Is the UR Dog equal in value to the Red Toxic? Do either have any special demand?

Looking for more opinions ^^

[Horror]

blue rose dog + ? = BMD

Valuing the BMD at a balloon dog, another two blue roses, or a skeleton PPS + 2 mid advents

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69557983&userid=650789&signature=4rIjKMf5RpSs-gh1MYxcCA

opinions about this?

Very unfair to you, while the demand on the peas is all over the place, they are still worth a main list at least. Their side is an advent list.

Thanks for the input! About how much more should they add? (if someone could tell me the value in rares as well as store pets that would be great!)

Edit: I was offered a dark blue toxic for the peas, is that under as well?

First one needs to add at least a very high september list just so it can be worth a bottom tier main list
The toxic could be fair or unfair to the peas depending how you value them, though you might be able to get more out of them

hey, can someone tell me if this is fair please?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7E2POdEFSg

Unfair to them, the GWJ is worth 2 sorbs + an apple, your side is worth a sorb + rainbow mane
Though since quantity can get overpay and the gwj might get underpay, it's up to you if you want to accept or not

[lukas_stop]

BA +green sorbet =UR peas?

I know they dont have a set value quite yet and demand is a bit wonky but would this be a good offer?

This seems pretty good since the BA has good demand, I think you could get a better offer but if not this sounds pretty good.

thanks! second opinions?

[may,]

i really need some expert advice on this

anyone?

[Plumsauce]

blue rose dog + ? = BMD

Valuing the BMD at a balloon dog, another two blue roses, or a skeleton PPS + 2 mid advents

thanks would a red rose pps fill the gap? or would more or less be needed?