The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[karachi]

which should I accept??

Trade 1

Trade 2

Trade 3

Trade 4

Trade 5

Trade 6

Trade 7

Trade 8

Edit: and this? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OyyBx1gORg

[agust]

What could be added to make this trade fair?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6nHrkNwEIQ

Because it's such a high list pet, you'd honestly have to add a sorbet. The two rares on the other side barely impact the trade.

[Mewfle]

I have 2 trades, both are for my Dogtag. And I would like to know if these trades are fair and if not who needs to add what?


DogTag Trade #1

DogTag Trade #2

Someone please help!

In the first trade, they'd need to add roughly about a non's worth.
No one can give you a correct answer for the second one, as the fox hasn't been placed on the list yet, but I highly doubt it would be placed on a tier higher than 2 nons.

[mango marmalade,,]

Hello everyone! Would this trade be fair? Thanks!!
xxxxx

[Mewfle]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69532474&userid=906333&signature=glDlMVL-3HS3u7ZkBiWwaw

That is quite a bit of overpay on their side. The dragon will most likely be an uncommon at most.

[Boredom Queen]

What could be added to make this trade fair?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6nHrkNwEIQ

Because it's such a high list pet, you'd honestly have to add a sorbet. The two rares on the other side barely impact the trade.

How much is the sorbet worth in rares?

[agust]

Hello everyone! Would this trade be fair? Thanks!!
xxxxx

It depends on what your pup grows up into. If it grows into a joker, they aren't even close to it's worth after demand, which is a sorbet if I'm not mistaken. If it grows up into a normal card dog, they are overpaying with their list pet.

[minoosh]

Was this a fair trade?
XXX

[Virelen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69517376&userid=880386&signature=fS05KPW37K7JsgQIfY4Cpw thoughts on this?

Your dog is from August 2009. A regular 09 rare, regardless of that, it's still worth more than their side.

nice, thank you. second opinion anyone?

[Boredom Queen]

What could be added to make this trade fair?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6nHrkNwEIQ

Because it's such a high list pet, you'd honestly have to add a sorbet. The two rares on the other side barely impact the trade.

How much is the sorbet worth in rares?