The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Kuro_]

this?
Also, what would need to be added to make this fair?

[CaffeinatedLlama]

Hey! I was wondering if this was a fair trade? I’m on the UR Bwolf side<3

[cribunni]

Can someone please tell me if I should accept this??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Slw0JyYtgQ
I rlly feel like I should because it’s a store pet! But that’s a 2009 rare so.. idkkkkk

[RainWingThing]

Can someone please tell me if I should accept this??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Slw0JyYtgQ
I rlly feel like I should because it’s a store pet! But that’s a 2009 rare so.. idkkkkk

I wouldn't, the store pet is only worth a late 2010 rare which isn't fair to you

[Zelda the Wolf]

I have 4 trades, 1 is for my line Tribal and the other 3 are for my Dogtag. And I would like to know if these trades are fair and if not who needs to add what?


Line Tribal


DogTag Trade #1

DogTag Trade #2

DogTag Trade #3


Also quick question - Grinner + ? = Target Dog

I can't help with 1 or 2 of those trades as 2 is mine.

But is only about 1 non and half. The lion adds no value to the trade.

Last trade is also the same...

[bookfanatic]

It doesn't seem very fair to them but if they are OK with it then I think you should take it. Just make sure they know that they are offering you more than you want for that animal.

[Rynder]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... s2ZCBS7p4A

The half with the ornament is overpaying a little bit. The lumanis fog was released last year in summer, and the ornament and tinsel were released in Christmas 2015.

[Gloob]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69525757&userid=806460&signature=bgIqWKutElu_qOJrMvxRRw

Is this fair?

[cribunni]

Can someone please tell me if I should accept this??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Slw0JyYtgQ
I rlly feel like I should because it’s a store pet! But that’s a 2009 rare so.. idkkkkk

I wouldn't, the store pet is only worth a late 2010 rare which isn't fair to you

Alright! Thanks for the help

[illicit]

I have 3 trades, 1 is for my line Tribal and the other 2 are for my Dogtag. And I would like to know if these trades are fair and if not who needs to add what?


Line Tribal


DogTag Trade #1

DogTag Trade #2


Also quick question - Grinner + ? = Target Dog

get a second opinion on this, but the first trade definitely looks unfair to me.
they are offering 3-4 '09 rares, which doesn't cover the gap between the two lists.

DT 1; unfair to the dogtag,
the gap between the dogtag and the coontail is 1 non.

DT 2; again, unfair to the dogtag,
it is worth 3 nons. they are offering one + eat me (valued at sorbet).

and the gap between the Grinner and target dog is an '09 rare
according to this helpful guide.

third dog tag trade added while i was answering this.
the pineapple is worth 2 sorbets and an ur apple,
and the value of the ur fox is not certain at the moment.
but i've rarely seen it go for more than 1-1.5 nons.