The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[nishi]

was this a fair trade?

is this fair and what would make it fair if not?

~nishi

[infinitestarsx]

On a Scale of 1-10 what would this be rated by you guys personally?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qvI4WuEMjw

I would like a few peoples rating please and thank you

Personally I'd say a 6.5, because even though it has a few rares for the Warrior Cat. Some can be traded for a bit of overpay depending if it's a users dreamie or not, while rats even though it's a '10 rare are hard as heck to trade off unless you find someone who likes rats and wants to catch em' all. Then, the rare Halloween pet is from '17 and isn't as sought out as the warrior cats are which also docks marks.

Thank you

Any other opinions?

i agree with jasper. this isn't even fair rarity wise

[Hot Dad]

I'd really appreciate some help, can someone tell me which 6 of these pets is worth the most?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=683704

I'm guessing its:
. Red cerb: 1-2 nons
. UR banana: 2 nons + yellow/green toxic (most likley just get 1 non tho)
. UR bee similar: 1-2 nons
. BEG: 1 non
. Blue toxic : above sorbet
. Jewled liontail: Sorbet

I'd love to know if this is correct or if a different pet in this group is worth more than one here.

[hashtag]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69224790&userid=890691&signature=Og1lHyyaT_nA6Ycf4rTkLA
Was this trade fair?

Yes! It was fair. Your pet was given 2x its value, rarity wise.
Demand wise, exactly fair. Your pet was an ‘09 staff litter pet. Most people value them at 2 ‘09 rares, other less. But once in a blue moon 3 ‘09 rares.
So depending on where you value your pet, concludes if it was fair or not.

To me, it was fair.

[hashtag]

I'd really appreciate some help, can someone tell me which 6 of these pets is worth the most?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=683704

I'm guessing its:
. Red cerb: 1-2 nons
. UR banana: 2 nons + yellow/green toxic (most likley just get 1 non tho)
. UR bee similar: 1-2 nons
. BEG: 1 non
. Blue toxic : above sorbet
. Jewled liontail: Sorbet

I'd love to know if this is correct or if a different pet in this group is worth more than one here.

The code is broken. Your calculations are correct though. (For UR Bee you could get 1-3 nons though)

[Hot Dad]

I'd really appreciate some help, can someone tell me which 6 of these pets is worth the most?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=683704

I'm guessing its:
. Red cerb: 1-2 nons
. UR banana: 2 nons + yellow/green toxic (most likley just get 1 non tho)
. UR bee similar: 1-2 nons
. BEG: 1 non
. Blue toxic : above sorbet
. Jewled liontail: Sorbet

I'd love to know if this is correct or if a different pet in this group is worth more than one here.

The code is broken. Your calculations are correct though. (For UR Bee you could get 1-3 nons though)

Okay thank you!
Does this work now: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=683704
: )

[Cacti.]

Is This fair? (warning lots of pets) I feel like I am underpaying them (i'm the grinner) I was thinking of doing my purple toxic instead of what I offered but I didn't know if that was fair

[Hot Dad]

Is This fair? (warning lots of pets) I feel like I am underpaying them (i'm the grinner) I was thinking of doing my purple toxic instead of what I offered but I didn't know if that was fair

Grinners are only worth 13-17 2009 rares!
Tier 7 dog is like 7-8 09 rares

This is INSANE overpay!
i would STRONGLY suggest you make this fair for them now knowing how unfair this is. Your pets are not worth this much at all. you are defo underpaying them.
This is practically the most unfair trade i've ever seen omg

[Hot Dad]

I'd really appreciate some help, can someone tell me which 6 of these pets is worth the most?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=683704

I'm guessing its:
. Red cerb: 1-2 nons
. UR banana: 2 nons + yellow/green toxic (most likley just get 1 non tho)
. UR bee similar: 1-2 nons
. BEG: 1 non
. Blue toxic : above sorbet
. Jewled liontail: Sorbet

I'd love to know if this is correct or if a different pet in this group is worth more than one here.

[nishi]

was this a fair trade?

is this fair and what would make it fair if not?

~nishi