The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[- Alice -]

is this fair? Unsure... I can only see two lists ;^;

[legoless]

Is this a fair trade?

[rookie rook]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68565578&userid=619341&signature=JX2edd4ul_n2xX9vaTMmAA

Is this fair?

Overtrade on the store pets side. Because it's out of store, it is worth much more than pets of it's release year. That store pet can get a 2010-2009 rare.

I agree, but for a completely different reason.

If a store pet is no longer in store it doesn't change too much of anything. A 2016 store pet is worth a mid 2010 rare (a 2009 rare would be an extreme overpay) so this trade was unfair for the flying rainbow dog. Hope this helped c:

[Smaug The Dragon]

What does the UR foal potentially trade for? How good is it's demand?
Would it be fair to trade a sorbet and non-balloon dog for one?

[Yammie]

Is this a fair trade?

Slightly unfair to the bottom. a 2014 store pet is worth a mid 2009 rare, and a 2016 store pet is worth a early 2010 rare. That means your side adds up to a mid 2009 rare, an early 2009 rare, and an early 2010 rare, while their side is three late 2009 rares. I think you would have to add a late 2010 rare or possibly an early 2011 rare to make up for it.

[SunRaes]

Hi! Would someone mind helping me out with this trade? Any and all help would be much appreciated!
(I figured this would be fair, as the Dogtag is worth 3 non-dogs, and the Zebra is worth 3 non-dogs+Blue Toxic..?)

[Cartier]

So I'm holding an auction for my non jeweled lion tail.

May I ask what bid is the best demand wise..
I know what's best rarity wise...
Bid 1
Bid 2
bid 3.
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8

[You don't to answer them all]

[shisho]

Hi! Would someone mind helping me out with this trade? Any and all help would be much appreciated!
(I figured this would be fair, as the Dogtag is worth 3 non-dogs, and the Zebra is worth 3 non-dogs+Blue Toxic..?)

sadly, the zebra only goes for 1-2 nons demand wise so this would be unfair to your trade partner demand wise.

[- Alice -]

is this fair? Unsure... I can only see two lists ;^;

[Smaug The Dragon]

What does the UR foal potentially trade for? How good is it's demand?
Would it be fair to trade a sorbet and non-balloon dog for one?